Uh, WHAT? I don't want to cross over into TMI territory here, but I have yet to have relations with a woman (and I'm happily tied to one, now) who didn't, uh, examine or otherwise verify the genuineness of my equipment.
I don't believe this for a second.
Good chance the “victim” only had experience before this with rigid plastic sort before and was not familiar how human ones responded to real sex.