Posted on 04/01/2015 1:37:45 PM PDT by SeekAndFind
During debates and speeches, politicians often bring up the financial burden that’s placed on the middle class. We talk about the middle class as though they are this singular entity, who used to thrive until they underwent persecution by the evil 1%. But, realistically speaking, the middle class and the 99% are not really synonymous. So, who are the middle class?
In its discussion of historical middle class societies, The Economist reports, “Their members are neither rich nor poor but somewhere in-between…’Middle-class’ describes an income category but also a set of attitudes…An essential characteristic is the possession of a reasonable amount of discretionary income. Middle-class people do not live from hand to mouth, job to job, season to season, as the poor do.”
Some argue that the most sensible income amount to attach to the middle class would be the median household income, of around $54,000. Perhaps, anyone who earns between the 25th percentile and 75th percentile is a member of the middle class.
Diana Farrell, once Deputy Director of America’s National Economic Council, told The Economist she thinks a middle class income begins at the point where a person (or family) has one-third of their income left over for discretionary purposes after they’ve provided themselves with food and shelter. In other words, someone who earns $3,000 per month would have $1,000 left after they’ve paid their mortgage or rent, utilities, and grocery bills.
Though there is some debate over the exact income a middle class household brings in, we do have an idea of who the middle class are — most working class people. Today’s bourgeoisie is composed of laborers and skilled workers, white collar and blue collar workers, many of whom face financial challenges. Bill Maher reminded us a few months back that 50 years ago, the largest employer was General Motors, where workers earned an equivalent of $50 per hour (in today’s money). Today, the largest employer — Walmart — pays around $8 per hour.
The middle class has certainly changed. We’ve ranked a list of things the middle class can no longer really afford. We’re not talking about lavish luxuries, like private jets and yachts. The items on this list are a bit more basic, and some of them are even necessities. The ranking of this list is based on affordability and necessity. Therefore, items that are necessity ranked higher, as did items that a larger percentage of people have trouble paying for.
1. Vacations
A vacation is an extra expense that many middle-earners cannot afford without sacrificing something else. A Statista survey found that this year 54% of people gave up purchasing big ticket items like TVs or electronics so they can go on a vacation. Others made sacrifices like reducing or eliminating their trips to the movies (47%), reducing or eliminating trips out to restaurants (43%), or avoiding purchasing small ticket items like new clothing (43%).
2. New vehicles
Very few people who earn the median income can afford to buy a new car or truck. Interest.com recently analyzed the prices of new cars and trucks, as well as the median incomes across more than two dozen major cities, and found that new cars and trucks were simply not affordable to most middle-earners.
“Median-income families in only one major city [Washington DC] can afford the average price Americans are paying for new cars and trucks nowadays.” As of 2013, new cars are priced at $32,086, according to the study. Mike Sante, Interest.com’s managing editor reminds us, “just because you can manage the monthly payment doesn’t mean you should let a $30,000 or $40,000 ride gobble up all such a huge share of your paycheck.”
3. To pay off debt
These debt statistics come from Debt.org:
“More than 160 million Americans have credit cards.” “The average credit card holder has at least three cards.” “On average, each household with a credit card carries more than $15,000 in credit card debt.” Not only do we have large amounts of credit card debt, we also have student loans, mortgages, cars, and medical debts. Our debt is growing faster than our income, and many middle class workers have trouble staying afloat. Money-Zine evaluated debt growth and income growth over the past few decades and found that “back in 1980, the consumer credit per person was $1,540, which was 7.3% of the average household income of $21,100. In 2013, consumer debt was $9,800 per person, which was 13.4% of the average household income of $72,600. This means debt increased 70% faster than income from 1980 through 2013.”
4. Emergency savings
To provide ourselves with a degree of financial security, we are supposed to have emergency savings to protect ourselves in the event of job loss, illness, or some other catastrophe. Most members of the middle class don’t have at least six months of emergency savings, however, and some working people have no such savings.
A Bankrate survey found that only around one out of four households have six months of emergency money saved, and many of them are in the higher income groups. Another one-fourth have no emergency savings at all, and the remaining household have a small to moderate amount of savings, but not enough to cover six months of expenses.
5. Retirement savings
If you reach the retirement age with little or no money saved, Social Security is probably not going to be enough to cover your basic needs. Even if you want to work for your entire life, you have no way of knowing whether or not you will be physically capable of doing so.
Although having a lack of a retirement savings is a risky move, so many people bet on double zero, just hoping that things will work out in their favor. While some members of the middle class neglect this aspect of financial planning because they are procrastinating, there are also some workers who cannot afford to set this money aside. Nearly half of those who don’t save for retirement say it’s because they simply don’t have the money.
As of late, around 20% of people near 65 have not saved anything for retirement at all, and the majority of people — 59% — worry that they don’t have enough money saved for retirement, according to a Gallup Poll.
6. Medical care
Medical care is a basic necessity and something we’d think would be affordable for someone earning a middle income. A Forbes article published data indicating that workers in large companies — many of whom are members of the middle class — “face nearly $5,000 in premiums, co-payments, deductibles and other forms of co-insurance.”
During the past few years, these costs have had a large impact on working Americans. A report by Feeding America found that a shocking 66% of households say they’ve had to choose between paying for food and paying for medical care — 31% say they have to make that choice each and every month.
7. Dental work
According to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, “the U.S. spends about $64 billion each year on oral health care — just 4 percent is paid by Government programs.” About 108 million people in the U.S. have no dental coverage and even those who are covered may have trouble getting the care they need, the department reports.
Oftentimes, people will purchase medical coverage and forgo dental because it’s so expensive. Plus, dental insurance may cover only 50% of the more expensive procedures, like crowns and bridges. This leaves those who have insurance with large co-payments.
In many cases, middle-earners will delay or even forego some of these procedures in efforts to save on costs. According to the CDC, nearly one in four adults between the ages of 20 and 64 have untreated dental caries (like cavities or infections).
Median household income is around 54K. A family of 4 with income in the 25K range will get around 6K in Earned Income Tax Credit, so is their income 25K or 31K?
At 55K this year, we were very average. However, we’ve saved hard our whole lives, own our house and are therefor considered by many to be wealthy.
Not all new cars run $30K. Many are much less. But no, when I was young, I didn’t own a lot of brand new cars either.
And growing up in the 60s, I don’t remember a huge number of vacations. What we took were mostly weekend vacations within driving distance.
Guess I don’t think this article is very honest about the present or about the past.
In contrast to my post on vacation spots, both my wife and I find our various doctor visits much less crowded, and appointments easier to get. I believe the large deductibles of Obamacare is the reason.
They are renting their lifestyle. I couldn’t sleep at night.
That's exactly what they do, and why they have no savings. It's a whole different world. From them I learned just how very popular the political demand for debt forgiveness is going to be - we already are hearing the first hints. There will be demagogues elected on its basis, and it won't be good for the country.
That was certainly the case in 2007/8.
McMansions with negative equity on zero down floating rate ARMs and two leased luxury SUVs.
The federal govt operates exactly the same way, LOL.
*
They left out “morality”.
I agree. In eastern Massachusetts (yeah, I know, but I grew up here and am holding my nose and refusing to move) about $100K would be the lower end of the middle class. Believe me, I know.....
Ain't that the truth.
My dad was an airline pilot for 30 years and I make more than he did and cannot afford vacations and only a new car every 8-10 years.
Honestly, it seems a little low to me but I would guess it depends on region. Still though, 15K plus the high rates has to be a killer.
Just claim you’re a make-believe black pig farmer. There’s $50,000 right there.
“So, you’re claiming to be a pig farmer and you were discriminated against by the government. I have a bunch of pictures of farm animals on the wall behind me. Which one is the pig?”
“Ummmm.....the one on the far right?”
“That’s the light switch. Here’s your check.”
Not buying it. Standard of living has never been better. Have you tried getting a table at Texas Roadhouse on a Friday or Saturday night?
I rest my case.
The peanuts! All those peanuts.
I think that figure obscures as much as it illuminates. I have seen figures that 30-50% of credit card holders do not carry a balance, and that those very high credit card debt figures are skewed to a very small percentage that have very high balances.
Helpful. Thanks.
I’m there with folks on the vacation piece. You give up other things on this list to do/pay for any of the others.
It’s whack-a-mole living.
I had a summer job back in the 70's working in the collection department of a bank in flyover country. Had to make a few late payment reminder calls to influential people with cc balances of $25K and above.
Some of the sources and facts in this article are questionable. Feeding America is used as a source about the availability of food? I’d like a second opinion please.
There are numerous statements in this article that need fact checking.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.