[yield 2 the right]

Tom Brady, all about the here and now, Joe Montana was so 1980’s/90’s...

[Fungi]

In the grand scheme of life, this is not important.

[SamAdams76]

4-0 in Super Bowls is pretty impressive. But Brady is currently 4-2 in Super Bowls and the two he lost went down to the wire. He could easily be 6-0 if a play or two in each of those two games went differently.

[yarddog]

Bart Starr, Joe Namath, Kenny Stabler. Bret Favre, Johnny Unitas, Take your pick All of them, but Favre, called their own plays so they had to be smart as well as be able to throw.

If I had to limit it to two it would be Roger Staubach and Terry Bradshaw. If I had to choose one to lead the team it would be Bart Starr.

[builder]

Joe.

[AnotherUnixGeek]

All due respect to Brady, a Bay Area product, but the Seahawks would not even have been in tonight's game if not for two Brady INTs. The first was an awful throw under pressure, and it killed a scoring drive. The second gave the ball to Seattle at the NE 35 and led to Seattle's go-ahead TD.

Montana never threw a single INT in the biggest game of them all.

And congrats to Brady for taking the all-time SB TD record from Montana tonight. In his sixth try. Montana did it in four, of course.

Of course, the Pats are an East Coast team, they're within shouting distance of ESPN in Bristol CT, and they'll get plenty of love from the East Coast media. But no amount of Bob Costas's gushing will make Brady as good as Montana, let alone better.

[clintonh8r]

Super Bowl wins are not the only criterion for greatness.

[boycott]

I’ll say Brady. Joe was more of a system QB. No doubt both are two of the best.

After that, Joe Namath. If he hadn’t hurt his knee, I believe he would be in the discussion too.

[discostu]

It’s gotta be Brady. Tied for the wins, more trips to it, more TDs in it. And he ain’t done yet.

[Gay State Conservative]

Y.A.Tittle

[Fiji Hill]

Neither. It was Morley Drury, quarterback for the USC Trojans 1925-1927.

[LegendHasIt]

Bart Starr

[Third Person]

Tommy Freakin’ Brady

[trisham]

Tom Brady is awesome.

[strider44]

Brady. Wins MVP again, and he gets to go home and drill Gisselle. No contest...

[tumblindice]

Of all time?
Y.A. Tittle.

Tittle dropped turds in the toilet bowl that were tougher (and some were bigger) than either of those two blow-dried, limp-wristed, metrosexuals. (Especially Brady.)

And his teammates said they were non-flushable. Tittle’s turds are reputed to have flexed and twisted in the commode, straining their muscles, fighting—refusing to admit defeat and be flushed.
And they actually grieved being separated from him. I don’t know how the Giants evicted them from the premises. A backhoe possibly.

[Charles Henrickson]

Both quarterbacks have won four super bowls with their teams.

Bart Starr won FIVE NFL championships with his team.

[dfwgator]

But the real question is, Who will be the better actor?

Brady in Ted 2, or Bret Fav-ruh in ‘There’s Something About Mary’?

[DemforBush]

Art Schlichter. He always covered the line!

[Charles Henrickson]

Otto Graham could be considered the greatest QB ever. He took his team to the championship game EVERY YEAR HE PLAYED. Still holds the record for the highest winning percentage of all time.