Posted on 01/07/2015 5:36:35 AM PST by silent_jonny
This is beautiful! No gimmicks. No spasm dancing. Just good singing. Really, really good.
Keith: Beautiful song. Good choice.
Jlo: Captivating. Magical quality to your voice.
Harry: I'm questioning the song choice. (In a roundabout way, Harry is saying the song might be too deep for Idol, but he liked it)
La-teen-card indeed. She looks as Mexican as a Eskimo.
Girls are not that good so far.((((Hugs))))
Shannon is singing out of the side of her mouth and I can’t get past it. Plus she mumbles.
I definitely prefer the guys this year.
Another good natural singer. This one is more upbeat that Katherine's.
Harry: We've seen a lot of polish. Wonderful thing about you is that you're so green but that will wear off. (needs to commit more to the song)
Keith: Not a good song choice. I like you.
Jlo: You are a phenomenal singer. You have to start believing that.
Idol producers are panicking as they do all they can to prevent another WGWG winner.
WGWG=white guy with guitar
Not lookin good.:)
Boy she started out rough.
And I’m not diggin’ the look. She is usually very pretty.
She sounded like a screechy spiritual. Yuck.
Oh, here comes “Shi”.
Let’s see if I can understand a thing she sings this time.
She goes for actressing when she's not singing.
Tries very hard to seem powerful, but the song sounds generic. Camera cuts to Jlo who's face goes from "when will this end?" to "this is the greatest song I've ever heard" in one second.
Jlo: Very brave performance. Good job.
Harry:Keith: It was good.
Let’s see if I can understand a thing she sings this time.
Nope.
Kiss of death comments from judges for SHI....
Yeah, but Sideshow Bob has the looks so that helps.
Add a "t" to Shi's name, because that's what this is. "Umbrella-ah-ah-AH-AH-AH!"
Jlo's "when will this end?" face doesn't change this time.
Keith: Powerful. Don't know if you got me with that song choice.
Jlo: You are an amazing singer. (voice trails off)
Harry: You're extremely talented. Wasn't the right song for you.
Ugg.
ROFL!
Flashes his gang signs at the camera, then sings a Phil Collins song.
“I’m cute” ain’t that great.
Non lipstick Maddie is a cute little thing.
Hope she can sing.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.