The other cat is rarely seen. They are just looking out the window mostly. The defiant cat will bite a hole in the bread bag just to do it. He must be anti-carb. He never ate the bread. So all plastic bags and food are kept in cupboards. Thankfully they have not figured out how to open the cabinets. I had an 18 year old cat who used to open cabinets all the time.
The dog likes peanut butter as well. I put it in her Kong. She also likes liverwurst.
Defiant cat! Good one.
He will probably never forgive you for the dog. That’s why he punishes you with trying to make your bread stale.