CJ Harris
His pick is from Meat Loaf: John Mayer's "Gravity".
CJ: It's real soulful, man.
Meat Loaf: He's gonna take us to church with this one.
It's okay. He's not straining his guts out like he usually does.
However, there's a painful expression on Jlo's face ... then she realizes she's on camera, and she forces a smile.
Keith: That's one of my absolute favorite Mayer songs. Good performance from you too. But if you're going to do an emotional song, I'd like it to be more of an arc ... with a crescendo.
Jlo: Every week, you're getting more and more comfortable. YOu gotta look for the moments that are going to lift the crowd. It's about creating a performance that brings everyone to their feet. I want that for you so bad!
Harry: I think you have arguably the greatest gift any singer can hope to have, is connectivity. Good or bad, you always connect. This was your best performance to date.
Seacrest asks Jlo about the "stank face".
Jlo says the stank face was a good thing.