Missing from the list are...
Billy Squier
Eddie Money
Bon Jovi
Axel Rose
Sammy Hagar
Kurt Cobain
Tito Jackson
Jermaine Jackson
Beck (not Jeff)
Meatloaf
Nick Gilder
...more to follow if necessary
Meatloaf? Eddie Money? Is anyone really suggesting that they were “rated” at all, let alone overrated. If you are having a conversation about overrated at a bar and someone said, “Meatloaf kind of sucked”, everyone would just nod.
i would add michael jackson. over-rated, especially after the early 1980s were over.