Agreed. Even when he was young and handsome (see below) there's just something a little off-putting about him.
If you want to really be creeped out, go Google some pics of what he looks like now.
Noel Coward reportedly said after the premiere that if Peter had been any prettier, the film would have been called “Florence of Arabia”.
Hey, be nice. The guy is 80 years old in a couple of weeks. We've all got to get old. Not sure why you two get the creeps from him. See some of his interview with Charlie Rose a few posts above that I posted. To me he's real, charming, smart, hysterical, and incredibly interesting. Not a phony bone in his body and nothing that I can see that's creepy.