Phillip Phillips
(2nd Song)
Is this a song? Just bunch of mushy Dave Matthews noise.
I'm not even listening to it.
Steven: Very entertaining, very off the wall. I think you found your niche. Nice going.
J-Lo: Pretty song. But a little too artsy. All of you have a shot to win, especially you, Phillip. There's a time and place for this kind of song, but this wasn't it.
Randy: I have to disagree to Jennifer. You showed your true colors once again. You are a true artist. I love that you show your artist side. P2 will always be P2. I love it, dude! Nice.
They praise Phillips for being true to himself, but criticize Elise for being true to herself.