Your argument has more holes than a wheel of Swiss cheese.
Alwaki was an enemy combatant commander, who made documented statements that he wanted to kill as many Americans as he could. He sent people out with the intent to kill Americans. The minute he became an Al Qiada commander is the minute he gave up all rights afforded to Americans. Alwaki may have been born here, but he was never an American. I for one am very happy knowing he is roasting in hell alongside Bin Laden.
Agree. Why would a scumbag who is killing and attacking innocent Americans and others on foreign soil get better treatment than some gang-banger shooting it up on American soil? Actively attacking and plotting to kill others ....you get a bead on them and eliminate the problem.