Posted on 04/14/2014 1:09:21 PM PDT by SeekAndFind
An entire new feedback loop of accreditation is necessary in the economy we have, and fortunately that feedback is within our individual control.
To paraphrase Donald Rumsfeld, we work in the economy we have, not the economy we might want or wish to have at a later time. And what characterizes the economy we have?
It's bewildering because nothing works like it's supposed to. For example, getting a college degree was supposed to guarantee a good job and an 80% lifetime wage premium over people without college degrees.
But in the economy we have, getting a college degree no longer guarantees a good job, or indeed, a job of any kind: 53% of recent college graduates under the age of 25 are unemployed or doing work they could have done without going to college.
The payoff for getting a college degree is declining while the risks of becoming a debt-serf due to crushing student loans is rising. The big premium that once accrued to college graduates is eroding for reasons of basic supply and demand: there are far more people with college degrees than there are high-paying jobs for people with degrees--even law degrees, MBAs and PhDs.
The entire notion that a college degree "signals" something valuable to employers is breaking down. In the good old days, earning a college degree proved that a student was hard-working and conformist--just what hierarchical corporations and government agencies want in employees. (The "signaling" value of a diploma is based on work by economist Michael Spence in the 1970s. In general, the signal indicates an attribute whose value is correlated with the difficulty and cost of the signal: the harder it is to get a degree, the greater the value of the signal it sends.)
But in an economy in which education credentials are in over-supply, that signaling mechanism is running up against a basic reality: a degree accredits very little about the student's knowledge, problem-solving skills or professionalism. A degree is simply a proxy of knowledge, not evidence of knowledge or useful skills.
Indeed, the study Academically Adrift: Limited Learning on College Campuses concluded that "American higher education is characterized by limited or no learning for a large proportion of students."
Signaling an ability to grind though four or five years of institutional coursework is no longer enough; the signaling needed to indicate an ability to create value must be much richer in information density and more persuasive than a factory model diploma.
A resume is equally thin on information that accredits a worker's knowledge, useful skills and professionalism. A resume is a public-relations summary that everyone knows has been tailored to present the candidate in the best possible light. And precisely how useful and trustworthy is PR in any setting?
Put yourself in the shoes of a hiring manager or potential collaborator: there is precious little useful information in either a diploma or a resume. As a result, human resources departments have been tuned to eliminate as many candidates as possible by signal-based winnowing rather than by the collection of useful information on the skills, knowledge and professionalism of the potential employee/collaborator.
Conforming to social behavioral norms and being able to grind through mind-numbing work used to be enough to create value in the economy--but this is no longer the case for high-value (i.e. well-paid) work. The "signaling" camp holds that a degree showing the student sat through four or five years of classes is sufficient to justify hiring the person. That the student learned essentially nothing useful doesn't matter; the entire value of college is in the last class needed to get the diploma.
This was true in the long postwar boom when the number of well-paid jobs expanded at a faster rate than the number of college graduates. This is simply no longer true.
In contrast to the "signaling" theory of value, the "human capital" camp holds that working knowledge is what creates value. If the student learns little critical thinking, real skills or practical knowledge, then a college degree has little value.
What if conformity and being able to navigate formal systems/bureaucracies no longer creates value or helps people solve real-world problems? In the economy we have, the "signal" value of a college degree has sharply declined. This is why college graduates can send out hundreds of resumes and not even receive a single reply, much less an interview or job offer.
Systems analysis teaches us that changing the parameters of a system (for example, adding another line to your resume or getting another degree) does not change the system; only adding a new feedback loop can change the system.
Clearly, an entire new feedback loop of accreditation is necessary in the economy we have, and fortunately that feedback is within our individual control: it's a process I call accredit yourself. The most powerful feature of accredit yourself is the process is open to anyone: recent college graduates, those without degrees, those re-entering the workforce, those seeking to launch their own enterprises--everyone who wants an income stream in the economy we have.
I outline the process of accrediting yourself in my new book Get a Job, Build a Real Career and Defy a Bewildering Economy
Getting a job is easy these days. Just be willing to do the work of three people for minimum wage, have a degree, and be a minority under the age of 40. Easy peezy!
PROFOUNDLY DISCONNECTED?
http://profoundlydisconnected.com/
A trillion dollars in student loans. Record high unemployment. Three million good jobs that no one seems to want. The goal of Profoundly Disconnected is to challenge the absurd belief that a four-year degree is the only path to success. The Skills Gap is here, and if we don’t close it, it’ll swallow us all. Which is a long way of saying, we could use your help…
Not here. We have plenty of jobs and the vast majority pay far more than the minimum wage. Where are you at?
I hear there’s a job opening at US Airways HQ, in the social media department.
Yup, plenty of jobs in San Antonio. Call center positions, I.T. and the are hurting for nurses.
I was going to open up a recruiting company to bring nurses from NY and NJ down here. Then I realized that would be more libs in Texas so I canned the idea.
DannyTN, CE
(Certified Emperor)
Qualified to rule wisely.
Emperor Accreditation by DannyTN Accreditations.
RE: I hear there’s a job opening at US Airways HQ, in the social media department.
Well, now that you’ve advertised it, how many are going to apply for this one position?
I hear Pelosi/Reid Accreditations is offering the new Certified Food Stamp Collector designation.
I hear Pelosi/Reid Accreditations is offering the new Certified Food Stamp Collector designation.
As a nearly life-long professional career counselor and recruiter, I can tell you that many occupations that require an associates degree or certificate pay better than many jobs that usually need a bachelors or masters degree. Examples are the trades, nursing home administration, medical technicians, robotics, etc., etc.
Not to mention the Pelosi/Reid Certified Congressional Family Slush Fund Recipient available only to close friends and family members.
The Philippines and many other Asian countries are chock-full of nurses and doctors. What would we have to do to get them here?
Me: six figures on a $2,300 ten month cobol course.
My 25 year old daughter got a civil engineering degree and got a job specifically for her skillset right after she grduated.
My 28 year old daughter got an accounting degree and entered the workforce as an accountant via contract work. She’s now a CPA.
My 31 year old daughter has a GED. I taught her about workplace etuquette and Business Analysys and she is now a SR BA at a large firm. She is the highest paid of the three girls, but her field of choice has a lower income ceiling. Big deal. It’s relative.
But college is not the key. To put it bluntly, learning a valueable SKILL and doing the equivalent of reading “How to win friends and influence people” (or any other self help guru) and applying it to your daily life will get most people farther than a college education can. Hard skills excepted (e.g. brain surgeon).
Things are slowing down on the IT side where I am and there is a hiring freeze plus a new automated production facility being built. Expecting half the people will be gone by next year.
If I get cut, I am open to getting out of SC.
Work is for chumps. Why work when you can get 4 years of unemployment, shifted to disability, before you even turn 25? If you REALLY want to hit the jackpot, move to Hawaii, get knocked up, and move in to public housing and watch the benis roll in.
Jacksonville FL. A town that ran off most industry because it wanted to be “green” and is full of military retirees who will work for peanuts.
Well, I am looking for a storage/server engineer in San Antonio.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.