Hope College.
I think you'd get argument over what town is "most religious." I haven't spent much time in Holland since leaving in the 1960's. It's small town, far enough from Michigan City, so I figure the change in character is slow. Still, I just don't know.
Great memories though. I'd say I had an exceptional childhood. Loads of freedom, loads of community.
I grew up in southwestern Jackson county in Hanover. There used to be a “Glory to God” garage in Hillsdale. They used to race a car at Butler Speedway.