[DManA]

The entire body of US law is internally contradictory.

When 4 justices use well reasoned arguments based on law and precedent to prove “A” and 5 justices use well reasoned arguments based on law and precedence to prove “NOT A” then the body of law and precedence MUST logically be internally contradictory.

Which means all legal decisions are totally arbitrary.

[OneWingedShark]

When 4 justices use well reasoned arguments based on law and precedent to prove “A” and 5 justices use well reasoned arguments based on law and precedence to prove “NOT A” then the body of law and precedence MUST logically be internally contradictory.

This is a result of case-law instead of constitutional law; the courts have elevated 'precedent' to a level superior to the constitution, and there are enough bad rulings out there they can make their opinion say whatever the hell they want.