“Keep your expensive butter”
Insider’s tip, Tillamook will be coming out with a premium butter, I think by June.
I love Tillamook! Always have a big block of Tillamook cheddar in the fridge. Tillamook ice cream is great. Their fruit yogurts are great too, and cheap, but my grocery store dropped that.
As for butter, I tried the big rolls of Amish butter and it was very good. Not good enough to pay the price though. Lucerne is the cheapest, the quality is just fine and I’ve eaten it since I was a kid.