Replies

The question was: ""If Free Will was demonstrated to be true, would you accept it?" You said you wouldn't, no matter how much proof

Again, we'll all wait for you to produce the post where I "said I wouldn't."

But, I do appreciate your participation in the demonstration.

The only thing that's been demonstrated is that you don't know how to run a demonstration.

For clarity's sake, here is your request and my answer...

To: Dr. Eckleburg
I answered your question.
Help me out then. Was it "Yes" "No" or "Maybe"?
978 posted on 07/15/2010 7:38:15 PM PDT by D-fendr (Deus non alligatur sacramentis sed nos alligamur.)

To: D-fendr
Are you stalling?
Yes. Sure. Alrighty. Definitely. Absolutely. But of course. Mais, qui. You betcha...

And here I "helped you out" and STILL you missed my answer.

I guess your free will has been trumped by mine. Imagine what God could do with that set-up. Do you think He knows about it?

Here, it seems perhaps I'll need to repeat your demonstration, this time with the opposite variation:

You asked me would I believe in free will if you could prove free will?

Actually, the question was: "If Free Will was demonstrated to be true, would you accept it?"

And I said yes.

Q.E.D. Assuming you made that decision consciously and freely of course.

I guess your free will has been trumped by mine.

Q.E.D.

Would you care to demonstrate again?