Bill Donohue: Over the line?

dotCommonweal ^ | David Gibson

[Quix]

Fine with me.

The data would essentially result in the same stats.

[Judith Anne]

I can’t find a single phrase in your response that resonates in the least remotely accurately to anything I said.

Odd, I quoted you.

[Quix]

I thought RC’s were familiar with

OUR FATHER WHO ART IN HEAVEN . . .

forgive us our sins as we forgive those who sin against us.

= = =

So, is this another case of my ignorance of what the RC’s are, in fact, familiar with and not familiar with?

[Petronski]

Stats that show raging anti-Catholic fetishism?

Yeah, I agree.

[Quix]

After how many twists, turns, editings, . . . of my words???

Fascinating, nonetheless.

[Petronski]

You’re quite wrong. If you want forgiveness, seek repentance.

[Petronski]

After how many twists, turns, editings, . . . of my words???

Demonstrate how many.

The number is zero.

[Quix]

You’re bothered because Catholics get to post threads on FR, and you’re bothered because you don’t like the titles, and because we can post anytime we want?

= = =

If I were to respond candidly to this set of inaccurate phrases, I’d violate a request of the RM.

[Quix]

The opposite, actually.

[Dr. Eckleburg]

Here's one: "Catholicism deifies Mary." It's demonstrably not true.

IMO Catholicism deifies Mary by calling her a "co-redeemer."

And anyone should have every right to say that anywhere on earth.

[Judith Anne]

Here's your post #328:

We prottys have to endure

hostile, trolling, outrageously titled and stated RC posts and threads virtually 24/7.

You don’t hear us whining anything remotely close to the RC whines.

328 posted on Friday, May 09, 2008 10:57:39 PM by Quix

My post was a request for clarification, to ask you if Catholic posting privileges bother you, nothing more.

[Petronski]

IMO Catholicism deifies Mary by calling her a "co-redeemer."

You are wrong, as has been demonstrated dozens of times.

You do not get to decide what we believe. We do.

[Petronski]

The opposite, actually.

You should add that to the end of all of your posts, or make it your tagline.

[Judith Anne]

IMO Catholicism deifies Mary by calling her a "co-redeemer."

And anyone should have every right to say that anywhere on earth.

Not on a Catholic caucus thread.

[Petronski]

Anyone has every right to lie, anywhere on earth.

[Petronski]

The record reflects who bayed with howls of protest at the idea that some threads might be designated “respectful dialogue.” The record further reflects who swarmed to sabotage the test case with bluntly disrespectful posts (most of which I flagged at the time).

[Petronski]

We know who is the father of all of that.

No thanks, I’ll stick with Christ.

[Judith Anne]

I wonder if that’s what is bothering our protestant friends, that Catholics have caucus threads where their insults, mocking, denigrating are not allowed...