Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

To: Gophack
Whoever you cut and pasted that from has an axe to grind. No need to rape the text. The pericope (and the Bible) is about Who is Christ?, not about Who is Peter? The person who confesses Christ as God incarnate (as Peter did) has said a mouthfull.

In fact... he's said a mountainfull. As Jesus, in effect, observed.

Dan

107 posted on 02/05/2002 5:32:14 AM PST by BibChr
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 86 | View Replies ]


To: BibChr
I re-read my post #86 and I didn't think that the people I quoted had an axe to grind. I thought they made a compelling argument -- using the Greek since you indicated Aramaic wasn't acceptable -- that because Peter was a male, using the female 'petra' would have been silly.

Why would Jesus say, "You are Peter, and upon this Rock I will build my Church" if he didn't mean Peter was the rock? Why change Simon's name at all? Do we know that Jesus used gestures to mean the rock was He? No, because that's not in there. Why would Jesus give Peter the keys to the kingdom of Heaven if he was a mere pebble? Why Peter? Why not Paul? Or John? Or Matthew?

I agree with you that the Gospel is of course about Who is Jesus? What did He say? What did He do? Jesus is the Word of God made flesh, and in that His flesh died, his body resurrected, and He is in heaven with His Father. Does that mean there is no church? That the church is in heaven, and were are but a bunch of spiritual beings loosely joined by our agreement that Jesus Christ died for our sins and our salvation?

I do believe that Jesus Christ established his church on earth, that He made Peter the foundation for His church, and that we have apostolic succession from then to now through the Bishop of Rome. The apostles looked to Peter, knowing he had the authority from Jesus Himself, for answers, as written in the New Testament. Early church fathers never disputed the primacy of Peter. Does this mean that Peter is equal to God or that we worship him? Of course not. We only worship God.

I know that Mt 16:18 is arguably the biggest sticking point between Catholics and other Christians, and I am sorry about that. I pray someday that we will be unified again. Until then, we have so much we agree on. And there is so much work here on Earth to do that we can join together in. For example, I am very involved in the pro-life community. I have many Protestant friends who help in pro-life work. By working together to end the horrors of abortion, we know that we are all brothers and sisters in Christ and can love each other, even if today we don't agree.

God bless.

115 posted on 02/05/2002 8:25:35 AM PST by Gophack
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 107 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson