I wouldn't agree that Juan is hated. I would agree with you if you said he is decently and brightly monotonous. How many new ideas have you gotten from him?
My personal impression, from watching Juan Williams so much, is that he is very, very, very, very, very, very, very (almost scarily) predictable.
That's why I wrote, up above, that it was nice that his appreciation for Bush's efforts against AIDS shone through on that day.
I'd love to see Juan express his spontaneous feelings more often.
I get all my new ideas from Sean Hannity and Fred Barnes. (/sarcasm)