[donh]

Like I posted earlier, Campion, donh is the anti-catholic version of a DU disrupter.

I was one of the first contributors to this web site, I was born catholic, and "disrupter" is an inappropriate epithet for someone who disagrees with you.

Anyone reading the documentation posted by you, Qwinn, and others will be impressed by the depth of your evidence

or, possibly, the distracting nature of said evidence which, while voluminous, has not generally answered the concern posed.

and the rather shrill nature of the attack...

uh huh. Could you point to an example of the "shrill nature of the attack?"

[jscd3]

I have already noted that you have not responded intelligently to any information posted by anyone else. You ignore or dimiss as irrelevant any and all evidence presented by individuals with superior theological and historical credentials to any you have presented.

In particular, your inability to register the fact that Jewish leaders that actually lived through the Holocoust publicly thanked Pius and expressed enormous gratitude for his aid loudly, publicly, and often, indicates an unwillingness to deal with history that varies from your point of view that borders on disorder.

Apparently, you are fixated on some notion of what you would have done if you were Pope; any child can engage in the game of "if I were king...". Given the circumstance of the day, which were a apparently a lot more complex in the real world then in yours, Pius did what was considered quite admirable by the people that he saved. That's not my opinion, that's the opinion of the founders of Isreal, who stated as much many times in public, in private, on the public record, and in their own notes and letters. Got a problem with that? Take it up with Golda..

You simply repeat the same attack without condidering the weight of what the folks who lived through the Holocoust said. Apparently you believe that your opinion is simply more important than theirs; if the historical record and the opinions of major players that actually lived through the awful events of the day differ from yours, well, they're, wrong you're right, that's that. Hey, it's a free country - you can have any opinion that you want, but that attitude of yours borders on foolishness. Hense the term shrill. Do you prefer adolecent?

Finally, I don't care how long you have been posting, or what religion you were, are, or will be. A disrupter is categorized by behavior, not personal experiances. Please do not bother responding...OK? Life's too short