[Exnihilo]

mutation as an information generation..

Mutation & natural selection themselves have not been firmly or even loosely established as an information creating mechanism. So either both ID and Darwinian evolution aren't "scientific" or they are, at least according to your criterion.

[ThinkPlease]

Mutation & natural selection themselves have not been firmly or even loosely established as an information creating mechanism. So either both ID and Darwinian evolution aren't "scientific" or they are, at least according to your criterion.

I didn't say that that was my criterion for evolution to be accepted. I'm merely explaining to you why ID theory hasn't done its job (yet), IMHO. That is what ID theoreticians feel they need to do to get their theory accepted.