[HairOfTheDog]

I do like this review for its depth. It is clear that the reviewer is intimately familiar with the books, and did not read them for the sake of the movie review.

[jrherreid]

Yep--the Tolkien junkie reviews are always better. I'm one myself, and have been trying to convince some of the more hardcore Tolkienites that the movie will be just fine. (And I never did like Tom Bombadil, anyway...)