Your message here is somewhat garbled. No matter what the rest of their “track record” is like, it’s better to be inconsistently right than consistently wrong.
Maybe because yes I think a religious adoption agency should have the right to place children as they see fit. But my point is that at least for me, right now, the Catholic Church stands for turning a blind eye towards the molestation of children on a mass scale, maybe even actively facilitating it. So when people look at them taking this principled stance that a gay couple can’t properly care for a child, but then they’re responsible for who knows how many children being sexually molested. I dunno, not a good look in my view.