[metmom]

Mary BEGAN to be the mother of the Second Person of the Trinity, who existed from all eternity, when He took a human nature by being conceived in her womb.

No, Mary began to be the mother of Jesus.

The Second person of the Trinity pre-existsed Mary before the Incarnation.

He did not begin with the Incarnation as your statement says.

[Arthur McGowan]

I said that the Son, the Word, existed from eternity.

You understood me to say that the Son, the Word, began to exist at the moment of the Incarnation.

There is no point discussing anything with you until you become familiar with the English language.

[ealgeone]

Catholics have a probkem with logic