My post had absolutely nothing to do with Catholicism.
Every syllogism is either valid or invalid. That has nothing to do with Catholicism.
Any person who, looking at a syllogism, refuses to answer whether it is valid or invalid, reveals himself to be intellectually dishonest.
The fact that you attacked me for being a Catholic, when Catholicism had absolutely nothing to do with what I said, demonstrates that you are an anti-Catholic bigot.
How very revealing of you ... you post syllogisms with faulty premises and expect everyone to admire your prowess with logic? LOL, trying to raise The Mother of Jesus to demi-goddess status IS catholiciism, and that’s why I call it ‘another religion’, another gospel, not Christianity.’ have fun with your faulty premises, dude, dudette, dudes.