ping
PFL.
I don’t think this is from the White Horse Inn folks.
The author’s first sentence is in error.
Christ founded the Catholic Church on the Apostles, the first Bishops.
Roman Catholicism, as we shall see, did not even exist at the time Jerusalem fell, and would not manifest for another three hundred years.
Really? And what is the event that marked this "manifestation"? When did it happen? Where is the outrage from all the good Baptists and Presbyterians who were around at the time?
Kauffman's "evidence" for this ahistorical assertion is a hodgepodge of cherry-picked citations from various church fathers, most of which prove that they did not have exactly the same theological understanding or devotional life as Catholics of 1500 or more years later. No kidding.
For example, citing Origen's beliefs about the Blessed Virgin proves what, exactly? Origen is not "St. Origen" because (a) he committed the sin of mutilation by castrating himself; and (b) he believed in "apocatastasis," the doctrine that all things (including the devil and his cohort) were redeemed in Christ.
Origen is NOT my touchstone of orthodoxy -- though he is useful when he reports on the beliefs, not of himself, but of the church of his day -- but is he yours?
Of course, Kauffman doesn't tell you that Irenaeus of Lyons, who is a canonized saint, and a spiritual "grandson" of the Apostle John (Irenaeus was a disciple of Polycarp, who was a disciple of John), calls Mary the "new Eve" in his tome "Against Heresies" -- written well before Origen appeared on the scene. Does Kauffman call Mary the "new Eve"? I doubt it; it doesn't help him trash Catholicism, and that's his real religion.
Then Kauffman inexplicably starts channelling Ellen Gould White, the founder of the SDA church -- is she his touchstone of orthodoxy … ??? -- with his rant on "Vicarius Filii Dei".
Except that "Vicarius Filii Dei" is not the Pope's name (or anyone else's), so that nutty assertion falls flat. It's not even one of the the Pope's official titles. I'll grant you that it's an accurate description of (one aspect of) the Pope's office, but that's all it is.
Of course, you can play the same silly game with "Ellen Gould White" -- write the "W" as "VV," and it sums to 666. I could write a screed every bit as sensible as Mr. Rocket Scientist's extrapolating the SDA to all of Protestantism, and ending with "Come out of her, my people," but then I would be as nutty as he is.