Replies

Theistic evolution means that it is evolution guided by God, Who is the sole Creator of the world from nothing. This is an allowable doctrine, but it is not the only allowable doctrine. A Catholic is free to not believe in any evolution at all, and generally take the Bible as literally as he wishes to. I happen to not believe in eveolution from species to species, for example, and I am an informed Catholic in good standing. In other words, your position is peculiar in that you argue for one Catholic teaching against another Catholic teaching, while not being a Catholic at all. This is a bit comical.

We further believe that Adam and Eve were physical historical parents of all mankind. This is a mandatory belief for a Catholic. If you want, I can research with greater precision what exactly the parameters of Catholicism are in this regard, -- I remember seeing several bullet points, but that would be offtopic for this thread. Or you can look it up yourself in the Catechism.

We do not teach that the Bible is mythology, that is solely allegorical. We believe that the Church interprets the Bible, and that the Bible contains poetic or allegorical language as well as concretely descriptive language. We also allow a wide berth in some scriptural interpretations and less so in others. As regards the first chapters of Genesis, I just outlined what is and what is not permissible Catholic interpretation.

We believe that the Bible is inerrant inasmuch as it pertains to the questions of faith. It may get geological, historical, or biological facts wrong inasmuch as the inspired author never meant the Bible to be a manual of geology, history or biology.

Anyone who wishes to interpret the creation account literally in every detail -- an extreme literalist as you seem to be -- is welcome to the Catholic Church with this belief intact. His condition will be no different as a Protestant creationist's condition is now vis-a-vis the less fundamentalist as a whole body of Protestants.

Theistic evolution means that it is evolution guided by God, Who is the sole Creator of the world from nothing.

That's funny. The idea that G-d guides evolution is called "intelligent design," and most evolutionists (including Catholic ones) reject them as "creationists in disguise." So how is a good Catholic evolutiionist to believe that G-d "guides" it without really "guiding" it, eh?

I thought according to Vatican I the author was G-d? What did G-d get wrong?

Thank you for admitting that Catholics reject total Biblical inerrancy, which was the point I was trying to make! You have made it for me!