Sure, Catholics are born again in baptism when the spiritual death of Adam is washed away.
Salvation is a process, not a subjective emotional event in someone's life. Just because a person has an altar call in a Baptist Church does not mean they will automatically be saved.
In that case, Judas is in heaven today.
2nd sentence of my post is a mistype. Word should be "wouldn't" instead of would. This is proven by the 3rd sentence.