[RaceBannon]

I agree completely. That is my point, that the waters were already there.

We only agree if you beleve the waters were created day one! :-)

[monkeyshine]

We only agree if you beleve the waters were created day one! :-)

You're right, we may not agree after all :-) We both agree that the waters existed before the heavens and the earth. Yet Rashi explains that the waters were not completed (perfected) until the 3rd day (which is why God does not say "it was good" on the second day).