Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

Why Europe Hates Israel
FREEMAN E-MAIL LIST ^ | November 29, 2001 | By Bret Stephens, an editorial page writer for The Wall Street Journal Europe.

Posted on 11/29/2001 3:56:50 PM PST by dennisw

 

 

 

Commentary  November 29, 2001

Why Europe Hates Israel

By Bret Stephens, an editorial page writer for The Wall Street Journal Europe.



BRUSSELS -- Yesterday, a Belgian court heard arguments from
lawyers representing 23 Palestinians, survivors of the 1982 Sabra and
Chatilla massacres near Beirut, that Israeli Prime Minister Ariel
Sharon should be prosecuted in Belgium for crimes against humanity.
Though Mr. Sharon almost certainly will never sit in a Belgian jail,
the trial could hardly be freighted with more significance.

More than a half-century after the Holocaust, a Europe awakened to
the importance of human rights is looking to sanction the leader of
the world's only Jewish state for a crime that was actually committed
by a Christian Lebanese militiaman, later employed by the Syrian
regime of Hafez Assad. And yet blame for the massacres seems to be
apportioned to Mr. Sharon alone. Why?

Sensational Indictment

The short answer is the Belgian legal system, whose well-meaning
laws lend themselves to this sort of opportunistic and sensational
indictment. A slightly longer answer is that many Europeans are
sincerely convinced that Mr. Sharon really is a war criminal, as a
BBC documentary attempted to show last summer.

                               But the real answer is that
                               European governments today are,
                               by and large, tacit enemies of the
                               state of Israel, much as they
                               might protest that they merely
                               take a more "evenhanded"
                               approach to the Arab-Israeli
                               conflict.

                               Consider a few recent examples.
                               In April, France voted to censure
                               Israel at the U.N. Human Rights
                               Commission in Geneva -- while
abstaining from a vote of censure against China. During his
diplomatic foray to Tehran in September, British Foreign Secretary
Jack Straw offered that "one of the factors which helps breed
terrorism is the anger which many people in this region feel at events
over the years in Palestine." The European Union has so far refused
to follow America's lead by freezing the assets of terrorist groups such
as Hezbollah and Hamas, with the European Commission's external
relations spokesman, Gunnar Wiegand, arguing that "Hezbollah could
play a major role in regional stability."

That Europe today should be hostile to Israel may seem a bit of a
mystery, not least given the usual sympathy of aims between
democratic states. The explanation comes in several parts. First, as
historian Howard Sacher points out, Europe's left sees in Israel's
political evolution a betrayal of its utopian ideals. It's easy to forget
that in the years following the establishment of Israel, many
Europeans looked to it as a model socialist country. They admired its
largely state-run economy and especially its collectivist kibbutzim.
Hundreds of young European leftists, most of them non-Jews, flocked
to these farms in the 1960s, looking for the kind of workers' paradise
they could not find on the other side of the Berlin Wall.

This fondness, however, evaporated after the 1967 war, when Israel
went from being the Middle East's underdog to its Goliath, holding a
colonial-like mandate over the lands that came into its possession.
Partly under the sway of Soviet propaganda, partly in keeping with
the fashion of radical chic, European leftists abruptly transferred their
allegiances to the Palestinians and the PLO, which in the 1970s drew
the likes of current German Foreign Minister Joschka Fischer to their
meetings. Meanwhile, successive Israeli governments veered to the
right. "The era when Yitzhak Rabin or Golda Meir could address their
European counterparts as 'comrades' at gatherings of the Socialist
International had passed," says Mr. Sacher.

There was also a shift of attitudes on the European right. With the
exception of Britain, whose notoriously Arabist Foreign Office has
dominated its Mideast policy under both Conservative and Labour
governments, much of the Continental right had at one time looked
on admiringly at "plucky little Israel." Thus, beginning in 1952, the
conservative German government of Konrad Adenauer provided Israel
with critical financial support in the form of Holocaust reparations,
while Charles de Gaulle's France helped to build its nuclear reactor at
Dimona.

But it was also de Gaulle who, in 1967, slapped an arms embargo on
Israel for firing the first shot in the Six Day War. Thereafter, the
hostility increased, partly because France fancied itself a champion of
its former Arab colonies, partly out of simple anti-Americanism. But
the chief reason, of course, was Europe's dependence on Arab oil. As
French President Georges Pompidou put it to Henry Kissinger during
the 1973 OPEC oil embargo, "You only rely on the Arabs for about a
tenth of your consumption. We are entirely dependent on them."

Since then, Europe's reliance on Mideastern oil has abated, but the
habit of reflexively seeking to appease the Arabs at Israel's expense
has not. In 1974, French Foreign Minister Michel Jobert toured the
Middle East, seeking to earn price concessions on oil for France by
mouthing a hard anti-Israel line. In 1980, the European Community
formally recognized the PLO despite the fact that Yasser Arafat had
neither made peace with Israel nor dropped his overt sponsorship of
terrorism. Currently, the EU supplies the Palestinian Authority with
the bulk of its foreign aid, even as much of that money goes
indirectly to funding textbooks describing Jews as monkeys and
vermin.

Given all this, many Jews have been led to conclude that what's at
work here is a thinly veiled form of anti-Semitism. But while there
might be some truth to this, it's easily exaggerated. Mr. Straw, of
German-Jewish descent, is clearly no anti-Semite, and the one bright
spot of Jacques Chirac's presidency has been his efforts to
acknowledge the sins of France's suppressed Vichy past.

Underlying Guilt

Underlying European policy is an uneasy sense of guilt. In the
immediate postwar period, Europe's guilty conscience worked in
Israel's favor. But in the postcolonial spirit of the '60s, the balance of
guilt switched to the Arab side: It was they who were being oppressed;
and it was Europe that, with its previous support for Israel, had
helped inflict the oppression. So Europe pressures Israel to withdraw
from the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, heedless of the dire security
consequences that such withdrawal would entail. That Israel has so far
refused to accede to this pressure stands as an infuriating rebuke to
modern Europe's fundamental conception of itself as the virtuous
defeated, free to pass judgment while absolved of the moral
responsibilities of wielding actual power.

Whatever the case, a foreign policy based on a combination of
left-wing disillusionment, French opportunism and all-around
cravenness cannot yield good results. With the U.S. State Department
increasingly leaning toward the European line on Israel, it's well that
the basis of that policy be properly understood.

 

 

 



TOPICS: Foreign Affairs; Miscellaneous
KEYWORDS:
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-20 ... 41-6061-8081-100 ... 261-277 next last
To: dennisw
Good article. It pretty well sums up the 'how' and 'why'. The north Europeans want to forget their guilt, the French have always been whores, and the rest are lost in their muddled liberal/socialist fantasies.

Most of them have very large islamic populations that they imported to bolster their demographic problems vis a vis their social welfare programs. They will find that those pensions to be very expensive.

61 posted on 11/30/2001 6:00:50 AM PST by beowolf
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]

To: Brian Allen
For myself though, for having taken your mate, Britain's self-appointed spruiker and little-Hitler-like online shopkeeper, to task a couple or six times for the arrant stupidity and fundamental dishonesty of some of his more ridiculous [But linked notwithstanding to his online toby-jug, totes and t-shirt shop] assertions as to once great Britain's capabilities and Turd-Way Benn-Blair's motives -- I've had a bit of a flogging in the form of the flinging of obscenities and other forms of personal attack lately around the buy our t-shirts, poofter-bags and toby-jugs sites -- and am not much interested in continuing down that road.

Brian:

That's it. The gloves are off. I told you to quit bashing my country, and you said you would - you are an utter liar.

As for the rest of your vomitous rant, I wouldn't stoop to spit on it. What the hell do you do - you claim to be an Anglophile, yet bash Britain at every oppotunity - it is like an obsessive compulsive disorder with you. And then when someone calls you on it, you have the nerve to be surprised. Then you call the person who calls you on it names behind their back - you haven't the courage to say it to anyone's face.

You're not a man, I'll grant you're barely a human being. You have no guts, merely the ability to take pot shots and hope no one is looking.

Ivan
62 posted on 11/30/2001 6:13:12 AM PST by MadIvan
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 48 | View Replies]

To: MadIvan; Brian Allen
sshh MadIvan you mustn’t wake Brian he is all tuckered out the poor mite after a full days hating he needs his rest for tomorrows hate fest.

Plus he is funny enough to go on the stage I always look forward to his replies its better than reading the comic strips.

Cheers Tony

63 posted on 11/30/2001 6:20:17 AM PST by tonycavanagh
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 62 | View Replies]

To: tonycavanagh
sshh MadIvan you mustn’t wake Brian he is all tuckered out the poor mite after a full days hating he needs his rest for tomorrows hate fest.

It was funny at one point, but he has been at this for months - and he promised he'd be a good boy, take his medications and tone it down. He has done nothing of the kind. That's enough.

Regards, Ivan
64 posted on 11/30/2001 6:22:43 AM PST by MadIvan
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 63 | View Replies]

To: AGAviator
Then the apologists go to work and dismiss it as Jew-hating.

Sure, make Israel and the US repent to the arab world, that's what you are advocating after all. Didn't the WTC teach your type of people anything?

65 posted on 11/30/2001 6:33:38 AM PST by lavaroise
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 9 | View Replies]

To: dennisw
A slightly longer answer is that many Europeans are sincerely convinced that Mr. Sharon really is a war criminal, as a BBC documentary attempted to show last summer.

Must be those same Europeans who view Arafat as a legitimate, peace-prize winning statesman.

In 1980, the European Community formally recognized the PLO despite the fact that Yasser Arafat had neither made peace with Israel nor dropped his overt sponsorship of terrorism. Currently, the EU supplies the Palestinian Authority with the bulk of its foreign aid, even as much of that money goes indirectly to funding textbooks describing Jews as monkeys and vermin.

*Gasp* Imagine that, I was right.

66 posted on 11/30/2001 6:48:08 AM PST by agrace
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: MadIvan
For myself though, for having taken your mate, Britain's self-appointed spruiker and little-Hitler-like online shopkeeper, to task a couple or six times for the arrant stupidity and fundamental dishonesty of some of his more ridiculous [But linked notwithstanding to his online toby-jug, totes and t-shirt shop] assertions as to once great Britain's capabilities and Turd-Way Benn-Blair's motives -- I've had a bit of a flogging in the form of the flinging of obscenities and other forms of personal attack lately around the buy our t-shirts, poofter-bags and toby-jugs sites -- and am not much interested in continuing down that road.

You're not a man, I'll grant you're barely a human being. You have no guts, merely the ability to take pot shots and hope no one is looking.

Thank you for sharing, Ivan.

Good to see you stripped of pretense and in your very best form, using FRee Republic's boards for the mounting of personal attack -- and to push your own barrow.

As for whether I would hope that one as obessive as you quite clearly are; if indeed it was you I was referring to; was one of those you refer to when you say "and hope no one is looking?"

[For only you can decide upon that -- and whether or not to identify yourself with the description you've quoted above -- or with any given description -- although if you can see yourself in any of my creativity, by all means help yourself] It certainly seems you have the ego for the task -- although -- one might well argue -- not the justification;

And: Tcch Tcch, Dear Ivan. Such an ego.

Fancy, for even an instant, wasting your energy wondering if, unprompted by your good self or by tony or jj or by one or another of your little gang of bovver boys -- I even remember you exist.

Warmest FReegards

Brian

[www.freerepublic.com]

67 posted on 11/30/2001 6:58:27 AM PST by Brian Allen
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 62 | View Replies]

Comment #68 Removed by Moderator

Comment #69 Removed by Moderator

Comment #70 Removed by Moderator

To: The Documentary Lady; NixNatAVanG InDaBurgh; dennisw; veronica
They hate Israel because in spite of fifty years of war, their standard of living is as high or higher than most European countries, and their high technology inovations have made them second only to the USA in scope.***

We American taxpayers pay for this too along with payments for Israel's foreign policy which most people don't know about. Without America...

How accurate.

Not counting the huge cost of WW-II, met [Through Lend-Lease to mainly Britain and the USSR] almost entirely by us, from the Marshall Plan until today we Americans have spent more than Fifteen Trillion Dollars on Europe's rebuilding and post WW-II defense.

And 90% of the populations of Europe's dead and decadent, tawdry, squalid and primitive little socialist states [And every last one of our own, as mentally-sick, liberals] still reckon they're morally superior to us! And look down their noses!

Go figger!

FReegards

Brian

71 posted on 11/30/2001 7:23:08 AM PST by Brian Allen
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 68 | View Replies]

To: The Documentary Lady
So far Israel is flying in the face of the U.S. You'd think that with all the help and money we gave Israel, it would at least make Israel stop and think, but no.

We are paying Israel to give up its territories to terrorists for the sake of Europeans - ever since Saddat got back the Sinai for Egypt and Europe. After all the US does not need the oil in the Middle East, it's Europe that needs it. All this posture is about US kowtowing to Europe, not Israel. Quite the contrary, Israel is the only state able to admire and kowtow to the US, but we keep ignoring that.

Of course it is very possible that Israel will tell ultimately the US to go take a hike, and the Bible prophecies will be realized when that happens. Duck for cover when that happens, because aside from the destruction of Israel, the US will have entered a state of dependency on the UN IMHO.

Israel is only a pretext to attack America. When Europe condemns Israel, Europe is taking the muslim and Marxist line against US supported Israel. It's an indirect attack and indication that Europe no longer views the US with admiration but as a competitor, if not a nation to be despised outright.

72 posted on 11/30/2001 8:12:23 AM PST by lavaroise
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 70 | View Replies]

To: dennisw
So Osama Bin Ladin made the Israelis murder 400 civilians at Qana with US weapons? And makes them arrest, beat, torture, and kill Palestinians every month?

More Israel-first obfuscation from the usual suspects.

73 posted on 11/30/2001 8:16:16 AM PST by AGAviator
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 25 | View Replies]

To: Brian Allen
Good to see you stripped of pretense and in your very best form, using FRee Republic's boards for the mounting of personal attack -- and to push your own barrow

What a hypocrite you are. I may have called you an idiot, but I never compared you to Hitler.

In terms of personal attacks, I asked you to quit bashing my country for no reason - attacks that no American would tolerate if it was coming from a Brit - you said you would, and you didn't. You are therefore a liar.

If you don't want me to kick the crap out of you, then adhere to what you said. It is very simple - stop Brit bashing, and I'll stop bashing you. Continue it, and I'll continue bashing the hell out of you and your so-called arguments, which are merely your deeply held hatred of the UK masquerading in your mind as some fundamental truth. It's a very rational arrangement - stop it, and I'll stop. Continue, and I'll hit you with every last weapon to hand. I have no doubt that any American faced with some anti-American wanker would do the same.

Ivan
74 posted on 11/30/2001 8:18:56 AM PST by MadIvan
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 67 | View Replies]

To: lavaroise
Didn't the WTC teach your type of people anything?

If America had spent one hundredth of the money reconstructing Afghanistan after they fought our war against our enemy, that it spends on the Jewish state every year, that does absolutely nothing for us, there would be no Al-Qaida in Afghanistan, no terrorist camps, and no narcotics cultivation. There would be a pro-Western model that all the Middle Eastern people could start to emulate.

And if it didn't give carte blanche to a Jewish state that murders the original inhabitants of the Palestinian lands, there would not be any causes for any of terrorists to support.

You take sides in wars, you're going to acquire enemies. That's why there weren't any attacks in Europe.

75 posted on 11/30/2001 8:22:30 AM PST by AGAviator
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 65 | View Replies]

To: Brian Allen
And 90% of the populations of Europe's dead and decadent, tawdry, squalid and primitive little socialist states [And every last one of our own, as mentally-sick, liberals] still reckon they're morally superior to us! And look down their noses!

The only grounds such European states would have to claim moral superiority is if they could hold you up as an example, Brian. The swaggering arrogance you accuse many Europeans of having, is perfectly reflected in the arrogance you display in believing in your own superiority, your divine right to criticise, your noblesse oblige in your sneering treatment of other nations. Ye without sin cast the first stone. You are not in a position to do so, Brian. Your colleagues are far better placed, but you are not.

Ivan
76 posted on 11/30/2001 8:26:34 AM PST by MadIvan
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 71 | View Replies]

To: AGAviator
http://web.cyberia.net.lb/qana/english.html

Hey loser! Above website says 103 dead...Not the 400 you claim. Get your lies straight before you post.

77 posted on 11/30/2001 8:34:11 AM PST by dennisw
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 73 | View Replies]

To: Lent
"The Jews' time in Europe was roughly as bad as it was in Arab Islamic lands for 12 centuries"

Really, the worst situation I ever heard of in the Arab world was when the Etheiopian Christians came and finished off the Jewish King of Yemen for burning up all those Najran Christians.

78 posted on 11/30/2001 8:52:33 AM PST by Patria One
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 56 | View Replies]

To: Patria One
Such a pathetic lying one you are.:

 


  Jews living  in the Middle East and North Africa after the onset of Islam were dhimmized, persecuted, murdered treated with contempt, their property and lands confiscated, etc. Your Arab Islamic brethren  had a lot of practice in massacring Jews. The following are some small quotes from Joan Peters, From Time Immemorial (1984): (Chapter 3 exerpts, footnotes not included)

The Jewish community of Syria became a refuge for Jews fleeing the Spanish Inquisition. For centuries under Ottoman rule, it has been maintained, the Jews were allowed to live "relatively secure", often prosperous lives--chiefly as merchants--in the mellahs. Spanish exiles were responsible for establishing many Jewish religious schools in DAmascus and Aleppo, and more than one Jew held the post of Finance Minister.
   But in Syria, as elsewhere in the Arab world, the "position of Jews was in many ways precarious."
   A thirteenth century Syrian Arab writer provided a classic example of the durability and consistency of the Muslims' traditional Koran-inspired demoniacal image of "the Jew" -- the image through which the Prophet Muhammed and his followers sought to avenge Jews for favoring Judaism  over the "new", seventh century religion. The Syrian wrote that:

......this [Jewish] group is the most cursed of all God's creation, the most evil-natured
                                 and the most deeply rooted in infidelity and accursedness. They are the most evil inten-
                                 tioned of mankind in their deeds, even they are the most ostentations in humility and
                                 sel-abasement...When they manage to be alone with man, they bring him to destruction
                                  they introduce, by trickery, a stupefying drug into his food, and then they kill him.

As dhimmis they paid the special tax, and their testimony against Muslims was invalid in the Syrian Courts. Jews bore many traditional dhimma discriminatory burdens:forbidden to carry arms; and "usually" prohibited from building or repairing places of worship. To those consistent humiliations were added the intermittent "oppression, extortion and violence by both local authorities and the Muslim population....One Jew who rose to the post of "treasury manager", at the end of the eighteenth century, ran the gamut of the schizoid Jewish existence under Muslim rule. In the first stage of his ascendancy, he was arrested, an eye was gouged out, and his nose and ears cut. In the second stage, he gained prominence "unique" for Jews, under the tolerant reign of a new pasha.....These people are always taken off in the last moment of their greatest apparent glory. True to this..."Hayyim the Jew" was executed in 1820 and his property was confiscated by yet another successor to the Syrian reign.

....According to reports from the Jewish community in 1839, however, it was the European consuls who insisted on the protection of the Jews---not entirely the beneficence of the occupying Arab government.

Libya...The seventh-century Arab conquest, taking fifty years to subjugate all of North Africa, brought Libyan Jews under the same fluctuating oppressive dhimma restrictions as elsewhere in the Maghreb...From that period forward, the Jewish population was, in one city or another, sacked cheated, and pillaged alternatively by nomads and Bedouins, with sterner penalties and banishment meted out arbitrarily, according to the whim of whichever Muslim tribal leader had at the moment defeated his rival...The twelfth century brought the barbarity of the Almohads to the eastern plains, and the Jews were severely persecuted "for the purpose of conversion" about 1140, "the blood of sons and daughters was spilt on a sabbath day...There is not a Jew, not a single one, in Dajayya or al-Mahdiya, and for Sabrat and Tura my eye always weeps".275   ....and the following mid-twelfth century description from another:

....years of distress, oppression and persecution to Israel, and they were exiled from their localities:
                      such as were for death, to death and such as were for the sword, to the sword, and...to the famine,
                      and...to the captivity...and such as were destined to leave the community left because the sword
                      of Ibn Tumart, who went forth into the world in the year 4902 (1141/2) and who had decided
                      to eliminate Israel...And so he left no name of them in the whole of his kingdom nor
                       remnant...from the end of the world to the city of al-Mahdiya.276

....In the late sixteenth century many of the Libyan Jews whose ancestors had fled the forced conversion of Spain ironically were faced with the choice of death---or conversion to Islam. "Hundreds" of Jews were murdered during the persecutions of Ali Gurzi Pasha's reign.281 ....Jews in other regions of Tripolitania did not benefit from the Turkish rule;they were subjected to forced conversion and anti-Jewish pogroms, and they shared the ghetto miseries suffered in other parts of North Africa.....Another plea came from the entire Jewish community of Tripoli----

                        ....The situation of the Jews in all parts of Tripolitania is very dangerous. >From all
                        the rights....we are unfortunately excluded by reason of extreme ill-treatment and
                        persecution at the hands of the Muslims in our country, under the...present [Governor]
                       ....who does not wish to...protect us against the cruel and inhumane Muslim population
                       ....Last Thursday, a Jew on the way to his village was killed by Arabs and his companion
                       was injured...the authorities have not attempted to find the criminals...to the Muslims
                       the Jews are of no account, and our personal safety is in jeopardy and our belongings
                       are not our own.285

Tunisian Jewry...an authenticated and respected document of that period [fifteenth century], written by a Flemish nobleman, describes Tunisian Jews as "despised and hated"....

                       The Jews, on the other hand have no freedom. They must all pay a heavy...tax. They wear
                        special clothes, different from those of the Moors. If they did not do so, they would be stoned,
                        and they therefore put a yellow cloth on their heads or necks;their women dare not even
                        wear shoes. They are much despised and hated, more than even the Latin Christians.193

....From the seventh-century Arab conquest down through the Almohad atrocities, Tunisia fared little better than its neighbors.196  The "complete expulsion" of Jews from Kairouan, near Tunis, occurredafter years of hardship, in the thirteenth century, when Kairouan was anointed as a holy city of Islam.197  In thesixteenth century, the "hated and despised" Jews of Tunis were periodically attacked by violence, and they were subjected to "vehement anti-Jewish policy" during the various political struggles of the period.

Algeria....the fate of Algeria's Jewish community was harsh....At the end of the fourteenth century, the Jews of the town of Tlemcen were persecuted to such extremes that one eminent historian states that there is no indication of "how indigenous Jews managed to survive the period of tribulations."170....Even on the edge of the Sahara Desert, the Jews were plundered and murdered. In late fifteenth-century Tu'-at, an "oasis" town, a sheikh incited the Muslims by accusing the Jews of "sorcery" and of arrogance of their failing to conform to the "discriminatory" codes; many Jews were killed and others forced to wear conspicuous and peculiar garb. This took place, ironically, in 1492, when the Jews were expelled from Spain and were wearily arriving in North Africa in search of respite from persecution.171  ....The Algerian Jewish community continued to bear the outrages of local "protectors" even after Algeria came under Turkish domination. In 1801 a would-be ruler promised, in return for assisting the overthrow of a rival, to give the soldiers "8 times their pay, white bread and the right to sack the Jews for three days."173  In the next fifteen years, hundreds of Jews were massacred; during one episode three hundred Jews were slaughtered within a few hours, while as the result of another carnage, the Algerian Chief Rabbi was decapitated. The murder of a Jew by a soldier sparked yet another bloodletting; while desecrating a synagogue, it claimed among its victims more than a dozen Jews who were at prayer.

Morocco...The history of the Jews under Arab rule in North Africa is turbulent and erratic. The conditions of their lives as infidels under the Charter of Omar might have been bearable under a more tolerant Arab caliph of one region, while at the same time, in another, Jews would have been under siege, or massacred.136 Practically from the beginning of the seventh-century Arab conquest, Jews were forced to live separately---in Morocco the ghetto was called mellah, while in Tunisia the Jewish area was hara. Some "Jewish tribes" had lived separately for "reasons of convenience", in some pre-Islamic periods, but now Jewish Quarters were imposed by the Arab conquerors of North Africa, with their "special Maghrebi" type of Islam---the "Malakite madhhab school most intolerant of non-Muslims," and "the establishment of the tariqas, mystical fraternities headed by religious fanatics."137 ....Because most of the Christian minority fled---those who had not been massacred or converted to Islam by the twelfth century 138 ---restrictions became increasingly harsh toward the Jew....Despite their general misery and deprivation, some Jews managed to accumulate wealth.141

However, most Jews were outcasts who suffered not only the traditional contempt of the dhimma code, but were subjected to imaginative interpretations thereof. Slaps in the face upon payment of the head tax, bullying, and insults were everyday occurrences. Rapes and looting, burning of synagogues, ripping of sacred Torah scrolls, even murder---all were "so frequent that it is impossible to list them."142 .....In 1032, 6,000 Jews of Fez were murdered, and still others were "robbed of their women and their property."143 In 1146, Fez was attacked by the Almohads [Arab Islamic], leaving "one hundred thousand persons killed." Marrakesh suffered similarly, when an unbelievable "one hundred twenty thousand" were slaughtered. According to an account of "eye-witness" reports, "On entering...the Almohads tried to convert the Jews to Islam by debate and persuasion..." until "a new commandment...solved the problem by a more efficient method. One hundred and fifty were killed...the remainder converted...."144  ....Those few Christians still in the region were "completely wiped out" by the Almohads, leaving the Jews as lone infidel survivors to suffer "the spite of the second Almohad generation."145 Forced conversion to Islam, death, or exile were the choices of the survivors of the Almohad massacres...In the latter part of the thirteenth century, "immediately before the founding of the New City [of Fez], the Muslims in the Old City rioted against the Jews."150 ....The "fierce persecution of 1640, called the al-Khada," was described by a victim of another assault, in a rare ancient manuscript; this report illustrates the rare instances of Jew insulting Muslim, the Muslims reaped vengeance upon the entire Jewish community with utter disregard for individual innocence or guilt....Down through the nineteenth century, the Jews' existence in Morocco remained insecure and tenuous, their misery often recorded by foreigners. The Jews were subjected at various times under Islam to "such repression, restriction and humiliation as to exceed anything in Europe."163

Egypt....Jews in Egypt, as in other Arab countries, lived at the whim of erratic Arab sovereignty. One Arab caliph invoked sunna (the "Muslim term for customs ascribed to Mohammed') to tyrannize the Jews and Christians in Cairo in the ninth and tenth centuries.101 One caliph, al-Hakim of the Fatimids, devised particularly insidious humiliation for the Jews in his attempt to perform what he deemed his role as "Redeemer of Mankind." First the Jews were forced to wear miniature golden calf images around their necks, as though they still worshipped the Golden Calf. But the Jews refused to convert. Next they wore bells, and after that, six-pound wooden blocks were hung around their necks. In fury at his failure, the caliph had the Cairo Jewish Quarter destroyed along with its Jewish residents, in 1012.103  The rule of the Ayyubids (1171-1250) continued the demeaning dhimma laws 104 and during the thirteenth-century reign of the Burji Mamluks, the Jews were particularly sought out for attack, with the result that the Jewish population "greatly declined".105  At the end of the thirteenth century, the poll tax, or head tax, was "reintroduced in Egypt, where it had fallen into oblivion,"106 and in the fourteenth century Jews were subject to "anti-dhimmi" mob "riots." With the reign of "mainly" Circassian-born Mamluks, "the prevailing attitude....was more severe than ever."107  In the sixteenth century, a religious fanatic wreaked terror among the Jews in Cairo. ".....From even those scholars who have documented the Arab persecution of Jews, there are accounts of a "flourishing" Jewish community in Egypt under the Ottoman rule. Yet Edward Lane's definitive report of the first half of the nineteenth century, which asserts that the "Jews...are under a less oppressive government in Egypt than in any other country of the Turkish empire,"110 puts the Jews role in general, and the relatively "flourishing" Egyptian Jewry, into a somewhat more realistic perspective by that report's description of Egypt's "less oppressed' Jews:

They [the Jews] are held in the utmost contempt and abhorrence by the Muslims
                                        in general...the Jews are detested by the Muslims far more than are the Christians.
                                        Not long ago, they used often to be jostled in the streets of Cairo, and sometimes
                                        beaten merely for passing on the right hand of a Muslim. At present, they are
                                        less oppressed; but still they are scarcely ever dare utter a word of abuse when
                                        reviled or beaten unjustly by the meanest Arab or Turk; for many a Jew has been
                                        put to death upon a false and malicious accusation of uttering disrespectful
                                        words against the Ku-ran or the Prophet. It is common to hear an Arab abuse
                                        his jaded ass, and after applying to him various opprobrious epithets, end by
                                         calling the beast a Jew...A Jew has often been sacrificed to save a Muslim.

...One historian has documented persistent blood libel persecutions throughout nineteenth-century Egypt--six separate instances between 1870 and 1892 alone, preceded by others---in 1844 in Cairo, where "Muslims....despised and sometimes abused the Jews," and even in such cosmopolitan communities as in Alexandria, in 1869.....Among the populous Muslim (fellahin) community, the Jews were not better off. A Britisher long connected with the fellahin through his Egyptian government jod, reported in 1888 that "....I think it would be difficult to discover which particular race is most hated (by the Egyptian fallahin) but I fancy that the Jew or Armenian would take the palm"...In 1890 an Egyptian version of the false charge "documenting" the "Human Sacrifices in the Talmud" was published in Cairo.114 Anti-Jewish "agitation" and persecution of the Jews in Port Sa was frequent between the 1880s and 1908...In 1926 the first Egyptian Nationality Code established that Egyptian citizenship would be offered only to those who belonged "racially to the majority of the population of a country is Arabic or whose religion is Islam."116  From the late 1930's, Egyptian nationalism, Arab unity against Zionists, and Nazi propaganda fused with traditional prejudice to ignite violently against the Jews.117 Often the destruction victimized other infidels. One such major incident was the burning of synagogues and churches, and other communal buildings belonging to non-Muslims.118

Iraq...The Iraqi Jews took pride in their distinguished Jewish community, with its history of scholarship and dignity. Jews had prospered in what was then Babylonia for twelve hundred years BEFORE the Muslim conquest in A.D. 634;75 it was not until the ninth century that dhimma laws such as the yellow patch, heavy head tax, and residence restrictions were enforced. Capricious and extreme oppression under some Arab caliphs and Mamluks brought taxation amounting to expropriation in A.D. 1000, and in 1333 the persecution culminated in pillage and destruction of the Baghdad synagogues. In 1776, there was a slaughter of Jews at Basra, and the bitterness of anti-Jewish measures taken by Turkish-Muslim rulers in the eighteenth century caused many Jews to flee.76

Aden....the general quality of life for Aden's Jews during the Arab reign was hardly "golden." The proximity of Yemen and the same dominating power indicate that Jews of Aden suffered conditions of humiliation under Muslim rule similar to those of the Yemenite Jews "until Aden was conquered by the British in 1839."59 ....

Yemen...Persecution was constant and extreme---stoning Jews, and "age-old" custom, according to "an old doctor of Muslim law,"37 was still common tradition at the time of the 1948 exodus...The Yemenite Jews' situation changed drastically for the worse in the seventh century with the Arab conquest. After the Jews who lived in what is now part of Saudi Arabia were either expelled by the Prophet Muhammad or obliterated, Jewish communities in the rest of the conquered Muslim territory fell under the new infidel status. The Jews of Yemen were subjected to the severest possible interpretation of the Charter of Omar, plus carefully devised brutal improvisations on the dhimmi theme. For about four centuries, the Jews suffered under the fierce fanatical edict of the most tolerant of all Islamic sects.40 .....In the twelfth century the conditions were so punishing, and formerly repugnant forced conversion to Islam was so sought by terrified Jews, that the "Great Rambam"----the venerated Rabbi Moses Maimonides---was prompted to write the famous "Yemen Epistle",41 in which he commiserated with Yemen's Jewry and besought them to keep the faith.....The eighteenth century was one of  almost unbearable burden, bringing the 1724 famine, in addition to insidiously varied humiliations and violence. Fanatical rulers ordered synagogues destroyed, and public prayers were forbidden. Many thousands attempted to follow "false messiah" Shabbetai Zevi on his pilgrimage to the Holy Land, but they were attacked on the way, and the Chief Rabbi of San'a was "tortured to death."42 ....One overlord decided to rid the Arabian peninsula of Jews by offering them a choice of religious conversion or banishment'the overwhelming number chose to leave the capitals and head for the Red Sea coast. Those who had not died of starvation, thirst, or illness during the torturous journey---for many, on foot----were allowed to settle down in a town called Mauza', where more casualties were caused by the cruelties of the climate. The Jews' exile was terminated by decree in 1781, according to one report, because the exiled Jews had been the only craftsmen in the country and the work was keenly missed.....Throughout the nineteenth century Jews were victims of hunger and of Arab attacks on the ghetto, which resulted in murder and pillage.

.....Contrary to the myth that Jews lived in harmony with the Arabs before the Zionist state, innumerable authoritative works document decisively the subjugation, oppression, and spasmodic anti-Jewish eruptions of violence that darkened the existence of the Jews in Muslim Arab countries...The Prophet Muhammad's original plan had been to induce the Jews to adopt Islam;4 when Muhammad began his rule at Medina in A.D. 622 he counted few supporters [Medina had a large Jewish population], so he adopted several Jewish practices----including daily prayer facing towards Jerusalem and the fast of Yom Kippur--in the hope of wooing the Jews. But the Jewish community rejected the Prophet Muhammad's religion, preferring to adhere to its own beliefs, whereupon Muhammad subsequently substituted Mecca for Jerusalem, and dropped many of the Jewish practices...Three years later, Arab hostility against the Jews commenced, when the Meccan army exterminated the Jewish tribe of Quraiza.5 As a result of the Prophet Muhammad's resentment, the Holy Koran itself contains many of his hostile denunciations of Jews6 and bitter attacks upon the Jewish tradition, which undoubtedly have colored the beliefs of religious Muslims down to the present.




 
79 posted on 11/30/2001 8:56:16 AM PST by Lent
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 78 | View Replies]

To: AGAviator; lavaroise
That's why there weren't any attacks in Europe.

There weren't any attacks in Europe because, apart from the fact there's nothing there to attack; the bloody attacks were mounted FROM Europe!

Conditions and attitudes in Europe's dead and decadent primitive and squalid little socialist shithole states incite and encourage, enable, incubate and facilitate these pre-medieval scum -- and send them on their way.

As often as not via North America's little outpost of Europe: Quebec!

80 posted on 11/30/2001 8:57:44 AM PST by Brian Allen
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 75 | View Replies]


Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-20 ... 41-6061-8081-100 ... 261-277 next last

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson