Posted on 09/27/2026 2:15:34 PM PDT by george76
10th Circuit Court lifts an injunction barring the filling of the expensive, controversial dam expansion in western Boulder County
...
Denver Water can finish its Gross Dam expansion and fill the controversial reservoir in western Boulder County, the 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled Tuesday, lifting an injunction by a lower court judge and confirming the dam’s permits as sound.
The appeals court said the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers had acted responsibly in issuing construction permits for the $600 million expansion, which is largely complete and will be filled using water rights Denver holds in the Colorado River basin on the western side of the Continental Divide.
While a federal district judge in Denver had issued the injunction after declaring the Corps had failed to consider less-damaging alternatives, or the fact that climate change could rob Colorado of river water, the appeals court rejected that view.
“We do not think the Corps’s choice of cost methodology was arbitrary or capricious,” the appeals court ruling said. The plaintiffs, including nonprofit Save the Colorado, argued the Corps rejected clear evidence of climate change, but the appeals court ruled the Corps gave the research fair consideration.
“The Corps considered — and rejected — the reliability of that and similar studies, one of which showed that in the Colorado River Basin, ‘no consistent trends in annual precipitation have been detected over the last 100 years,’” the appeals court said.
“In the end, the environmental groups ask us to substitute our judgment for the Corps’s. They point out scientific studies that, in their view, rebut the Corps’s reading of the scientific literature and ask us to opine on what the scientific research establishes,” the appellate ruling said. “But our job is not to second-guess the Corps’s assessment as long as it rests on a reasoned basis.”
Denver Water said it looked forward to completing a crucial water supply project it began permitting 23 years ago.
“We’re pleased to see the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals confirm that the Gross Reservoir Expansion Project was lawfully permitted by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers and that Denver Water can proceed with the final stages of this critical project to ensure a safe, secure water supply for the 1.5 million people we serve,” according to a statement from spokesperson Todd Hartman. “With this decision, Denver Water can move forward with completion of construction, site preparation and eventual filling of the expanded reservoir. An expanded Gross Reservoir is vital to the future of the Denver region.”
...
Save the Colorado’s Gary Wockner, who has led battles against many projects threatening to further alter the ecology of Colorado river systems, said the appeals court decision doesn’t change Colorado’s water challenges.
“It’s nonsensical to be putting more straws in, and further draining, the Colorado River at this point in history,” Wockner said. “That the law allows it to happen doesn’t make it right, it just makes it legal. I saw something wrong, I stood up, spoke out and took action. It was the right thing to do and I would do it all over again.”
Wockner said Tuesday the plaintiffs would not be appealing the decision to the U.S. Supreme Court.
Gross Reservoir Dam backs up South Boulder Creek, while also taking in water through the Moffat Tunnel under the divide, from the Fraser and Williams Fork rivers in the Colorado River basin. Denver Water has said the expansion is needed to balance its water storage system currently heavily concentrated on the southern end of the metro area.
Colorado Ping ( Let me know if you wish to be added or removed from the list.)
earlier =
Colorado state budget deficit grows to $1.6B as Medicaid costs soar..
https://freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/4396581/posts
SOMEONE EXPLAIN TO ME WHAT A JUDGE KNOWS ABOUT WATER—_ESPECIALLY VS THE ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS.
Gross Dam’s $600 million expansion is largely done .. June 14, 2026 ..
https://www.denverpost.com/2026/06/14/gross-reservoir-denver-water-appeals-court/
Coal-burning Comanche 3 power plant back in service after a year of repairs..— the largest generating asset on Xcel Energy’s Colorado grid ..
Shut down since August 2025, repairs to the plant in Pueblo could cost as much as $26 million, most covered by insurance.
https://coloradosun.com/2026/09/24/comanche-back-online-pueblo-xcel-energy-coal/
“Save the Colorado’s Gary Wockner, who has led battles against many projects threatening to further alter the ecology of Colorado river systems, said the appeals court decision doesn’t change Colorado’s water challenges.
“It’s nonsensical to be putting more straws in, and further draining, the Colorado River at this point in history,” Wockner said. “That the law allows it to happen doesn’t make it right, it just makes it legal. I saw something wrong, I stood up, spoke out and took action. It was the right thing to do and I would do it all over again.”
Wow. Could it be that Mr. Wockner is starting to have a dim realization of the notion that issues such as this should be decided through political, not legal processes? That judges aren’t super legislators who can substitute their judgments for those of representative bodies?
Unlikely. He’s a zealot who lost this one but will be more than happy to keep shopping for corrupt judges who’ll impose his views on society
Fill it up and fire up the coal!
The enviro-nazis should be forced to pay the legal costs of the defendants and the court.
The voters in California several years ago mandated that more reservoirs be built in California. The democrats have ignored this and have built none plus they even empty existing ones like the two in the Pacific Palisades area and they are still empty! A liner is being placed then a new cover where none was needed for nearly 70 years as it is for fire fighting only.
“Colorado state budget deficit grows to $1.6B as Medicaid costs soar..”
I never thought much of Governor Perry here in Texas, but he got one right - he rejected the expansion of Medicaid (for Obamacare) that was being dangled in front of governors, since the feds would initially pay for virtually all of the extra. He basically said “When the feds offer goodies like this, it never ends well. I don’t know how it would bite Texas, but it will bite Texas.”
He NAILED it, on Medicaid, at least.
Great googly moogly
A reservoir is a place that holds water or other liquids for future use.
We have been doing this for literally millennia.
Thanks, George.
Soooo many Californians and Northeast Leftists in Colorado now. Soiling their next nest.
Water management is critical. We must have reservoirs. Leftists sue to stop water storage. While the Statehouse in Denver buys water from the Arkansas Valley while selling the Colorado River to other states.
Leftists want all the water, then sue the people that provide the water.
For those that don’t know, the headwater of the Rio Grande starts in Alamosa, Colorado.
Commies gonna Commie.
It’s surprising that they have so much of Other Peoples’ Money.
NOT to say that there aren’t too many claims on the water in the Colorado.
Everybody out there needs to get a system to extract their water directly from the Atmosphere.
I’ll just note that here in the East I have to pay $100+/Quarter for what us essentially a rain tax [and my property drains nothing directly to the street for any rainfall].
Harvesting water from dry cold air is not easy or cheap or energy efficient.
It can be done it’s how much are you willing to pay per gallon not per 1000 gallons per gallon.
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10073925/
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2949821X26002218
From my ME brethren and as a ASME member myself.
https://www.asme.org/topics-resources/content/6-innovative-atmospheric-water-generators
This tech will be needed if biological humans ever want to colonize a desert eyeball planet around a red or orange dwarf star as the hab zone on those stars is under 1 AU all planets will be locked to the star like the moon is to earth with one face always pointed at the star hence the eyeball name. Why even bother? Red dwarfs and orange together are 80% of all stars in the milky way billions of them and they have lifespans into tens of trillions of years far longer than any other stars our own sun will cook us in 4.5 billion years really closer to 1 before the oceans boil off and we do the Venus thing not from CO2 or climate change from the sun burning out its H2 and switching to He fusion this will start the red giant process and eventually 4 ish billion years swell the sun so much it literally eats earth but far before that the output rises and the hab zone shifts out past 1AU and we steam before we roast.
Now if the AI and our silicon superintelligence children are to get off this rock we need to look for terra firma Proxima b is likely an eyeball world 4 light years away and to a silicon lifeform a 10000 year sleep is a blink of time with fusion plasma rockets 10% C is possible so that’s 42 years to Prox b and 10000 to a 100 light years bubble there are dozens of known planets inside 100ly most are going to be around red dwarfs as those stars vastly all others. They will still need water harvesting tech to leach silicon from rocks via NaOH silicate cracking done in hydrated form. I guess if you had 1800+C temps you could do the cracking too either way you must break the SiO4 bond one of the strongest in the universe. Math its universal and Gibbs is not a nice guy.
Why aren’t these people forced to pay for the court costs and cost overruns caused by their actions?
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.