Posted on 07/05/2021 2:00:24 AM PDT by Jyotishi
Correct.
I can only imagine the awe that neighbours of Rome felt for Rome. Just like the barbarians surrounding China. They saw this eternal empire that dominated culturally, religiously and economically not to mention militarily.
So they wanted to differentiate themselves from it.
This is probably analogous to the Bulgarian setting up their Autocephalous church when the Bulgarian Tsar was in conflict with the Roman Basileus.
I think if we dial back to 400 AD and see the monophysite controversy, which to me seems like arguing over eating the egg big end up it small end up. The camps fell into
Monophysite: the non Greek parts of the empire, mainly the Egyptians and Armenians. This was a way to differentiate themselves from the Roman’s.
Perhaps this is Lso related to the Khazars embracing Judaism when they were stuck between a Christian Roman empire and a muslim Abbassid caliphate.
Also analogous is https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Safavid_conversion_of_Iran_to_Shia_Islam#:~:text=The%20Safavid%20conversion%20of%20Iran,spiritual%20bastion%20of%20Shia%20Islam.
The Safavid conversion of Iran to Shia Islam was a process that took place roughly over the 16th through 18th centuries and turned Iran (Persia), which previously had a Sunni majority, into the spiritual bastion of Shia Islam
The Safavids created a distinctive Iranian identity once more by embracing Twelver Shiaism.
Pardon me for yapping on, but I’m thinking of more examples where the rulers would encourage a distinct religious belief to distinguish themselves from their neighbours and rivals
1. The Irish and Polish with Catholicism, though this seems to have been first local before the elite hopped on
2. The northern German nations with Lutheranism.
3. Druze, Alawites, even Jews and Parsis.
Religion, culture m language are all intermixed. Change one and you have a nation created, or killed off. The Manchu are dead, assimilated into Han China, the Turks subsumed all the Anatolian nations, the Bulgarian Turkic rulers were subsumed into their slavic subjects just as the Viking Getmanuc Rus were subsumed into their slavic people.
Further east the Kushans, originally Tocharians became absorbed into Indian Indian Hindu culture obtaining a distinct sub caste of kshatriya.
Good points.
One of the patterns is that if you are a small power next to a large one you embrace a faith different enough to keep your cultural independence, but similar enough that you can still claim to be coreligionists of the hegemon next door.
One example of this is the Alawites, whose beliefs have next to nothing to do with Islam, but who claim fervently to be a branch of Islam as that allows them to survive in their part of the world.
If the Islamic conquests had stopped upon the death of Mohammed, they would have been a small state next to the strong Byzantine one. The movement may well have adopted a Christian identity to survive.
Instead the Muslim Empire became the most powerful state in the world. It is only at that point that Islam was asserted as a distinct religion superior to all others.
You mean the Church of Climatology?
That’s the one. All genuflect before the Saints Barnum, Hubbard and the Holy Lysenko.
Thanks!
Moho was just one of many “magicians” vying for control of trade routes and settlements after the power vacuum that resulted from the decline of Byzantium and Sasanian empires.
Archeological evidence, which we’re not supposed to recognize, shows violence and decline of centralized rule before and during the time of the rise of Islam.
In short, and as the Islamic State once explained in an unambiguously titled article, “Why We Hate You & Why We Fight You,” “We hate you, first and foremost, because you are disbelievers.”
Read More: https://www.frontpagemag.com/fpm/2021/05/islamic-temper-tantrums-raymond-ibrahim/
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.