Skip to comments.Judge Rules State Can’t Stop Pro-Lifers From Reading Bible Outside Abortion Clinic
Posted on 12/04/2019 11:49:43 AM PST by Morgana
Iowa pro-life advocates won a legal victory this fall when a federal judge ruled in favor of their right to free speech outside of abortion facilities in the state.
Anthony Miano and Nicholas Rolland, both of Davenport, are pro-life advocates who stand outside Planned Parenthood and other abortion facilities in Iowa to be a voice for unborn babies. They stand on the public sidewalks, read aloud from the Bible, preach and speak to people walking in and out of the abortion facilities.
In 2018, they challenged a state law that prohibits loud and raucous noise in the vicinity of any residence or public building which causes unreasonable distress to the occupants thereof, according to the American Center for Law & Justice, a well-known pro-life Christian legal group, which represented them.
The AP reports U.S. District Court Judge Rebecca Goodgame Ebinger ruled in the pro-life advocates favor on Sept. 26. Then on Monday, she ordered the state to pay $130,000 for legal fees for Miano and Rolland, according to the report.
This is an important victory for our clients, for pro-life advocates and the unborn, and for free speech, the ACLJ responded.
The pro-life preachers challenged the law after Miano was prosecuted for a violation just for spreading a message of hope and peace outside abortion clinics, according to the ACLJ.
They argued that the state law violated the First Amendment by restricting the public from commenting on important issues like abortion.
In essence, these individuals were threatened with a prosecution for engaging in protected speech outside of an abortion clinic, ACLJ Director of Policy Professor Harry Hutchison said. We challenged the constitutionality of the Iowa law which makes it a misdemeanor to make a loud and raucous noise in the vicinity of any residence or public building which causes unreasonable distress to the occupants, thereof.
In September, the federal judge agreed that the law was unconstitutionally vague and violated free speech rights, the AP reports.
Pro-life advocates called Ebingers ruling a victory for free speech.
Essentially, this law was unconstitutionally vague, and second, dependent on the reaction to third parties, Hutchinson said. Were happy to report that the judge found in favor of our clients on the merits. Essentially the statute was declared unconstitutional.
Here was the post I did last night...
Note that Ebinger is a Leftist appointed by Obama.
Decisions like this are wrong even when they go in our favor. Freedom of speech is not freedom to be heard. In-your-face "free speech" is wrong whether it comes from pro-life folks at abortion clinics or antifa folks blocking highways (which isn't even speech, but that's a different issue).
Since 1973 seems like pro lifers have had less free speech since ANTIFA. ANTIFA does far worse stuff and police does nothing to stop them, and punishes us when we dare drive through them. The media freaked out when Trump called ATIFA what they are terrorists, yet the media demonizes pro lifers every chance they get.
Agreed. This decision also gives the lefties the right to congregate outside conservative's homes to harass and intimidate them, like what happened to Tucker Carlson.
What? Their page turning isn’t too loud?
Obviously great news but after 3 more great sc picks t the great will just say are you tired of winning. mt rushmore
She was appointed by Obama, but I believe she’s a Republican.
Thanks for a Biblical peek into the
Except that personal residences should be exempt. If they hate Tucker that much, then they can protest outside Fox studios.
At you service, brother.
Yes, Republican. I was was shocked by this. Well, broken clock.
I can’t believe this one slipped past Bammy. Wonder how she is on the 2nd Amendment?
Above and to 6
Another quick snippet - FWIW
Oh you were already on the ping list probably -— oops
Republicans held firm control of the Senate at the time of her nomination and confirmation. Doubtless a trade-off of some sort.
Ah - OK - TFTI
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.