Posted on 12/27/2017 10:11:07 AM PST by Kaslin
We've been having some fun at the expense of Nancy Pelosi and the Democratic Party's literally apocalyptic hyperbole and rhetorical overreach about the new tax reform law, showcasing examples of businesses -- large and small -- that are celebrating passage of the landmark legislation by paying out employee bonuses, raising wages, expanding, and making charitable investments. For what it's worth, here are a few additional examples that have cropped up since our last pre-Christmas post on the matter. As we await more announcements from corporations and small businesses across the country in the new year, I'd like to go back and underscore two significant developments that Matt covered over the holidays -- they're both really important.
First, in a video I flagged as "must watch" on Twitter, CBS News delved into the personal finances of three families across the country to determine how the new tax law will impact them. Each household cut distinct profiles; a low-income single mother in North Carolina, a pair of middle-income married educators in Rhode Island, and married small business owners with three kids in California. One thing that all three families had in common: Anxiety about the GOP plan. None of them were optimistic about how the new system will affect their pocketbooks, with two families explicitly anticipating a tax hike. This reflects widespread public opposition to the bill, driven by aggressive misinformation from the Left. When an accountant ran the actual numbers, however, all three households discovered that their tax burden was going down. Watch the entire thing:
Breaking news: @CBSThisMorning asked three families for their tax returns and found that all three would receive tax cuts next year because of the #TaxCutsAndJobsAct. pic.twitter.com/xnGvTgV3bJ— Senate Republicans (@SenateGOP) December 22, 2017
This really should not be a surprising outcome in the least, given that 80 percent of filers will see tax reductions under the bill -- yet this number cruncher's mathematical verdicts came as happy relief to these taxpayers, who'd succumbed to relentless propaganda and media malpractice. But reality did not comport with Democratic talking points. National Review's David French analyzes the importance of the CBS news segment:
Please watch this. The surprise and relief on these taxpayers’ faces is palpable. I wonder why they’re so surprised that their taxes are going down? https://t.co/23GR6auqWj— David French (@DavidAFrench) December 22, 2017
This is exactly the dynamic Republicans are hoping for in 2018. Democrats and many members of the media relentlessly claimed the bill would hurt the middle class. They called it a “giveaway” to corporate America and to the very rich. Polls indicated that large numbers of Americans actually thought their taxes would increase. In other words, the public debate served mainly to obscure the truth and conceal the benefits to working families. So what happens when reality intervenes and Americans by the millions see their take-home pay increase? The GOP’s hope is that it will lead to a public reconsideration and a rebound in Republican fortunes at the polls. And that’s certainly possible. There has been an enormous amount of doom-mongering in the media and online, and if Republicans can keep America safe and prosperous in the coming year, and if family fortunes continue to improve, then some of the hysteria may lose its bite. Eventually people tune out Chicken Little.
Click through to read his alternate scenario, which should concern a party that already trails heavily on the generic Congressional ballot. Meanwhile, Vermont Socialist Bernie Sanders -- who falsely described the Republican tax bill as a "massive attack" on the middle class -- was forced to admit that actually, 91 percent of middle class earners will receive a tax cut under this "massive attack," calling it a "very good thing." What a rhetorical shift:
.@jaketapper: “Next year, 91% of middle income Americans will receive a tax cut. Isn’t that a good thing?”@BernieSanders: “Yeah, it is a very good thing. And that’s why we should’ve made the tax cuts for the middle class permanent” #CNNSOTU https://t.co/ei8xTHGo1E— CNN Politics (@CNNPolitics) December 24, 2017
Ninety-one percent. Bernie's complaint about the law is that the individual rate cuts were not made permanent. Republicans built in a "sunset" date for the tax cuts (a point we've addressed multiple times) so that they would hit certain revenue and budgetary targets in order to comply with reconciliation rules. Permanent tax cuts would have shown up as more lost revenue, thus growing deficits larger than their budget rules would allow. Senate Democrats, well aware of this dynamic, offered an amendment to make the cuts permanent, which would have blown up the bill (yes, Republicans could have radically altered the bill, trading away other measures they believe will spur economic growth to make the individual rate cuts permanent). Republicans voted it down. But remember: The only reason that the GOP was forced to play these numbers games was because they needed to pass the bill with a simple majority. Why? Zero Democrats in either chamber were willing to go along with their plan. Now that the bill has been passed and signed into law, and considering that Democrats got a lot of mileage out of the "corporate cuts are permanent, but individual cuts expire" attack, Rich Lowry has a good idea:
First thing Republicans should do when they are back is make Democrats vote on extending all the middle-class tax cuts https://t.co/YVSd9q8XLy— Rich Lowry (@RichLowry) December 24, 2017
We've been arguing all along that the "expiration date" exploited by liberals to advance deeply misleading and cherry-picked claims about the legislation was always a fiction. Recent experience and strong political incentives each dictate that middle class tax cuts will not be allowed to disappear eight years down the line. Sanders just confirmed that on CNN. If one of the most liberal members of the Senate wants those cuts to be permanent, Republicans should oblige him with a vote. Tailor a new bill very narrowly to permanently extend the new law's tax cuts that benefit working class and middle income Americans. Bring it up as a stand-alone bill, "fill the tree" on Senate amendments, then let the Democrats vote on it. If they vote yes, they'll explode one of their only reasonably-defensible arguments against the bill (their alleged concerns about deficits -- a serious issue, I might add -- are laughable) while essentially conceding how helpful the law really is to middle income Americans (contra their entire mendacious messaging strategy). If they vote no, they'll be opposing their own idea, confirming that they cynically offered it just a few weeks ago solely as a means to derail the legislative process; they'd also highlight how the Democratic Party is the only party standing in the way of avoiding the future middle class tax hike about which Congressional Democrats say they're so terribly worried. Jam 'em, Paul and Mitch.
I'll leave you with a few additional examples of the misperceptions and lies that have taken root, which bear no resemblance to reality. First, I had a liberal relative in California inform me over the holidays that the majority of Californians will see tax increases because of the Republican law. In fact, 87 percent of Californians will receive a tax cut in 2019, with a vast majority (67 percent) still in the "winner" column even in 2027 -- after the unlikely "expiration" of cuts. The story I linked cites a poll showing a majority of California voters opposing a law that will directly benefit nearly nine in ten taxpayers. And then there's this bonkers column, which attempts to recast a sweeping tax cut -- benefiting 80 percent of households, and reducing taxes on average across every income group -- as "by far" the "largest tax increase" in American history. This is upside-down, pants-on-fire, utterly false, propaganda:
Criticisms of the tax bill are growing increasingly unhinged and bizarre.
Apparently the bill's legitimate criticisms (of which there are several) are not sufficiently apocalyptic.https://t.co/8dNxZZCXcC— Brian Riedl (@Brian_Riedl) December 23, 2017
The column's author and his editors should be embarrassed to have run these lies. And then there's this:
Two viral #taxreform tweets -- one from a celebrity, one from a random dude -- have been shared & liked hundreds of thousands of times. They're both factually false. Tax law maintained teacher/supply deduction, and SS/Medicaid sent no such letters based on invented claim: pic.twitter.com/HJfRGMFKnL— Guy Benson (@guypbenson) December 24, 2017
The sheer volume of lies and misinformation flying around about this law is frustrating and very telling.
BOOM: And so it begins...
Republicans should rub their noses in it just like Dems might do if it turns out that the opposite is true.
And Republicans and Trump — don't be nice about it. Be mean!
It's time for the BOOM drinking game! Every time someone makes "BOOM" - we take a drink!!
Boom: Shock and Awe...
Boom: Alibaba surges...
Boom: Major GOP momentum...
BOOM: ISIS: Leader Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi Dead
BOOM: Milwaukee Police Chief Explodes...>"
BOOM! We Just Spent...
Boom: Canadian troops and ISIS...
BOOM: What Do Charles Manson & Mohammed Have In Common?
Boom: This Column Contains...
BOOM: It Took Just 3 Minutes...
BOOM: Egypt Sentences Muslim Brotherhood...
BOOM! Newt Gingrich SLAMS...
BOOM: Dad Who Beat Pervert...
BOOM! Krauthammer Just Dropped...
BOOM: Rating the GOP field on Amnesty
BOOM! Netanyahu REFUSES...
BOOM! Veteran’s Message...
BOOM: Veteran Attorney Reveals...
BOOM! This is what EGYPTIANS think...
BOOM: Obama Takes Credit...
BOOM! Trump tweets...
BOOM! ALLEN WEST...
Boom: NC Congressman...
BOOM: Donald Trump’s...
BOOM – Univision...
BOOM – Univision...
Boom: Franklin Graham...
BOOM: Sheriff David Clarke...
BOOM: Caitlyn Jenner...
BOOM!! TRUMP DOES IT AGAIN!!...
BOOM, There It Is...
Boom! Trump...
BOOM: These 16 States...
BOOM: Trump SCHOOLS Liberals...
BOOM ! ...– CBS Poll: Trump...
BOOM: Cruz Demands...
BOOM! Frank Luntz...
BOOM! Ted Cruz...
October 21, 2015: BOOM:Trump...
Boom: Explosive...
BOOM: Country Music...
BOOM! Frank Luntz...
BOOM! Karl Rove...
Boom: State Dept...
BOOM! Andrea Tantaros...
Boom: Cruz 40, Trump 30...
BOOM! Trump Advisor Stephen Miller...
Boom! Democrat Party...
BOOM! Trump ...
BOOM! Trump ...
BOOM – Trump ...
BOOM! Hillary Clinton...
BOOM! Establishment Congressman...
Gotta Pay the Bills (BOOM!...
BOOM! This may be the BEST...
BOOM! Don't Blame The Whites...
Boom he's killing the kids'...
Boom boom boom-he's killing the kids...
(Youtube video uploaded on April 9, 2016) Boom!...
BOOM! Bernie ...
Boom! Trump ...
BOOM: 25 Questions...
BOOM Navy Veteran...
BOOM: @WeSearchr...
BOOM! SMUG NEWSPAPER...
Boom! Hard truth...
BOOM! Trump...
BOOM! Richard Grenell...
BOOM! Democrats Leaving Their Party...
Boom! The American Media...
Anonymous - Boom!...
BOOM! Dem Pollster...
BOOM! Hillary...
BOOM! Documents Show...
BOOM! Patriot’s QB Tom Brady...
BOOM! Dem Pollster...
BOOM! Soros Behind Busing...
BOOM! TED CRUZ...
BOOM: It Only Takes Trump...
BOOM: It Only Takes Trump...
BOOM: Rush Limbaugh...
BOOM: Looks Like Ted Cruz...
BOOM: Trump NAILS Obama...
BOOM! HOUSE PASSES BILL ...
Boom! Ted Cruz...
BOOM: Tucker Carlson...
Boom: Surge in support...
Boom: Record 27 million guns...
Boom: Record 27 million guns...
BOOM! PEOTUS TRUMP...
BOOM! CNN Caught...
BOOM!
(BOOM!)
BOOM!
BOOM!
BOOM!
Boom!
BOOM!!!
BOOM!
Boom: Trump eyes..
Boom!
tv online......boom!
BOOM!
Boom:
Boom: Wa8ll would save taxpayers...
It Begins: Illegal Immigrants...
Boom!...
Boom!...
BOOOOOOOOM!
BOOM!
Boom
BOOM
BOOM!
BOOM!
BOOM!
BOOM!
BOOM!
BOOM!
BOOM
BOOM!
BOOM!
Boom!
BOOM!!
.....boom.
BOOM
BOOM!
BOOM!
Boom!
BOOM! Trump Just Drained The SWAMP
Boom! Circa News Says..
BOOM!!
BOOM!
BOOM!
BOOM!
BOOM!
Boom!
Boom.
Boom!
Boom!
Boom!
BOOM! Pro-Russia Hacker Site..
BOOM!!!!!!!! ..
"BOOM! President Trump ..
BOOM!
BOOM!
Boom!
Boom! There ya go.
Boom!
BOOM: Acting ICE director
BOOM! Kid Rock...
BOOM! Report=> McMaster...
BOOM! Kim DotCom.....
BOOM! American Manufacturing.....
BOOM!
BOOM! Trump Slams Socialism
BOOM!
Boom, Boom and BOOM!
Boom!
*BOOM*
Boom.
BOOM!
Hannity tweeted, "Boom!!..."
BOOM !"
Boom.
Boom! That's going...
BOOM! DC Lawyer...
BOOM!
BOOM!
Milo slays liberal TV panel – BOOM!
Crossed the yeller line. Boom!
March for Science.....BOOM !
BOOM! Pamela Geller..
*boom*..
Let me be the first to say it....boom.
BOOM! Matt Drudge..
BOOM!
BOOM!
BOOM!
BOOM!
BOOM!
Boom.
BOOM!!!!!
BOOM!!!!
BOOM
BOOM!
BOOM! Charlie Daniels..
BOOM: DOJ Begins...
BOOM......BOOM.....BOOM DA BOOM DE BOOM
Boom!
BOOM!
Boom: CBS News Report..
While this list is not complete, it demonstrates the fun you and your family can have at home while making BOOM!!
So bottoms up everyone!
The only time you want to make predictions about how bad the tax plan will be is:
1. Before it’s passed, to try to keep it from passing.
2. After it’s passed, because you have hard evidence that the predictions are spot on accurate.
If you do number two, and it proves that you are dead wrong, well, it will not go well for you.
If this thing really does have the impact Pelosi is predicting, she’ll do well. OTOH, if it brings the positives many are predicting, this will hurt the dems, even if they had been quiet. Those that argue, after it was passed, just how terrible it will be will themselves be seriously damaged goods.
Back in the day, the MSM had a short memory. The internet and social media has a very long memory.
This is not rocket science although the Lying Left and their Keynesian Economics buddies try to make it so.
TAX CUTS ALWAYS directly benefit those who end up paying less taxes and indirectly benefits others through an improved economy.
The only entity that doesn’t benefit from tax cuts is the miserable government which illegal 80% portion needs to be dismantled anyway.
Bernie was against it before he was for it....
Chuckle
Must. Control. Internet.
The serfs cannot know the truth.
And if Bernie and 8 others would have voted with the Republicans they COULD have made it permanent.
The only reason it isn't permanent is because DEMOCRATS refused to make it permanent.
I sure hope that you don’t expect me to click on all those links, LOL
“....And Republicans and Trump — don’t be nice about it. Be mean!....”
Absolutely!!! Shove it in their faces at every chance.
Where’s that big azz gavel that that PeeLousie, that lying, dumb-looking Lewis and all were marching around with after odongocare? Find it and shove it up PeeLousie’s azz....sideways. Oh wait, don’t do that, she’d probably like it.
Anyway, just do everything that can be done to insult these commie POSs.
I guess JumRob can shut down FR for the rest of the day while we all click on Tom’s links.
Great article-concise and to the point about the fake info out there-the talking points are totally contrary to the facts-and democrats are so busted...
I don’t know any business owner or individual-includng myself-who is not going to pay less-as self employed/subcontractor, I won’t be getting hit with an automatic $1000 + when I make enough to pay taxes on-and my guy will be paying about $2200 less on the income from his computer and graphics business, as well as having a bit more take-home pay from his day job.
I have to ask-what is the purpose of this BOOM! stuff on practically every article of consequence-I don’t see the significance of it...
“@BernieSanders: “Yeah, it is a very good thing. And that’s why we should’ve made the tax cuts for the middle class permanent””
After seeing the benefits, Trump should announce sometime in May, the benefits be made permanent and he wants the bill on his desk no later than June 30th. Then let them vote on it prior to the election.
Great idea!
Bernie wouldn’t let a doubled wealth redistribution plan go without his grand approval... And a great big one it is! Pelosi, Schumer n Sanders dream come true.
Only in Washington DC could they brag about a tax cut that wouldn’t even cover a dinner out for the pol and his wife.
bkmk
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.