Massively improbable < Infinity
that is completely irrelevant. A massively improbable event continues to be massively improbable for infinity. Infinity is just the amount of time (endless) that it continues to be massively improbable to the point of impossibility. It is just infinitely impossible. Again, you are engaging in "the gambler's fallacy".
God says 'show me'.
Scientist says first you take this dirt..
God interrupts "Get your own dirt!"