What you fail to grasp, is that the disagreement isn't over the moral standing of police officers, which anyone can be informed on.
It's SPECIFICALLY about what goes on here at FR. If you've got a join date a month old, you obviously can't have an informed opinion on what goes on at FR.
What is the standard then? Three months, 11, two years?
And what do you mean, “...what goes on a FR.”?