One moment she is the New Reagan and Practically Perfect in Every Way ,(and don't you dare suggest that she needs to do her homework before running for President), the next she is a Dirty Rotten Scoundrel RINO for having the audacity to support the man who plucked her from obscurity and made her a star.
I see you caught that too. ;-)
I think if you Palin critics tried actually making a rational, fact based argument dealing in specifics about Palin instead of making these sort of ad homine attack, your side might get some traction.
These sort of "she doesn't know what she is doing, she is dumb, she is a hick" no matter how elegantly dressed up don't resonate with Conservatives. Stating "She needs to do her homework" while offering no specific examples of where she has not is a personal attack, not a serious critic of her.
None of you Palin critics are making a fact base argument. All your arguments boiled down amount to you all staiting this to "I don't like Palin". Unfortunately for you all that is not going to sell to Conservatives.
The sort of personal attack politics driected at Palin based on vague generalizations and opinions-stated-as-fact is why the Palin critics gain no traction here. The Palin critics debate tactics mirror what we on the Right are use to hearing from those on the Left. We are naturally inclined to ignore those who engage in those sort of debate tactics.