Here is my response to this tactic:
"Excuse me, Mr. Muslim, but I have a life, so forgive me if I don't feel like devoting the next several years of it to learning Arabic and then studying the Koran just to find out whether the clear evidence of my own eyes is accurate when it comes to the hundreds of millions of Muslims who proclaim and demonstrate that they want to kill me and destroy my beloved country.
"Moreover, in the event that I did put in the time to learn Arabic and study the Koran, and did come to the conclusion that it is indeed a peaceful non-violent religion, am I then supposed to judge that all the self-proclaimed Muslims in the world who take a different viewpoint are therefore not true Muslims?
"If I am put into the position of having to decide who is and who isn't really a Muslim in order to protect all that I hold dear, are you willing to abide by that judgment, and to allow me to treat such non-Muslims in a way that would deny them the ability to "hijack" the Muslim faith by depriving them of its trappings, customs and practices?
"May we kill them freely, without worrying that you will take our necessary actions as an attack on your own pure and true faith?
"I am not going to get into that kind of pointless and time consuming exercise, Mr. Muslim.
"So let's cut to the chase. It is very clear to anyone who cares to look that the Muslim world is riddled with the fatal disease of violent Islam, and frankly, it is up to the Muslim world to clean up the problem and contain the disease.
"Since it has failed to do that, and continues to fail to do that, then don't blame me if my own self-preservation and the self-preservation of our nation requires that we at last quarantine the disease, and fight it aggressively where ever its failure to contain its millions of psychopaths represents a threat to me and mine.
And if in fact, the Muslim world is so terminally ill with hatred and violence that it cannot contain this threat by itself, then don't fault me when I come to the obvious conclusion that it will have to be sacrificed to destroy the virus once and for all."
Could not argue it better. Muslims, leftists, and any others that spout ridiculous fallacies, always take their screwed up logic and throw it back in their face.
A well written article with a conclusion conservatives knew instinctively all along.