Instead of quizzing that other fellow, could you please explain or link, please, how the Advisory Committee is appointed? (I found out how it's done 2002-present, but nothing about how it was done previously.)
It is the MAYOR'S advisory committee on the judiciary. The mayor selects the members. He can also refuse any of the judges that are selected by the committee and send it back to the committee to come up with another name. It is obvious that Giuliani did not, as Mayor, prove that he works to appoint conservative, "constructionist" judges. That's why his CampaignSpeak(tm) promises now ring very hollow to those who know his actual record and who aren't willing to gulp the KoolAid he's passing out.