Skip to comments.Judge orders 'gay' agenda taught to Christian children
Posted on 02/24/2007 4:17:13 AM PST by Man50D
A federal judge in Massachusetts has ordered the "gay" agenda taught to Christians who attend a public school in Massachusetts, finding that they need the teachings to be "engaged and productive citizens."
U.S. District Judge Mark L. Wolf yesterday dismissed a civil rights lawsuit brought by David Parker, ordering that it is reasonable, indeed there is an obligation, for public schools to teach young children to accept and endorse homosexuality.
Wolf essentially adopted the reasoning in a brief submitted by a number of homosexual-advocacy groups, who said "the rights of religious freedom and parental control over the upbringing of children would undermine teaching and learning "
David and Tonia Parker and Joseph and Robin Wirthlin, who have children of school age in Lexington, Mass., brought the lawsuit. They alleged district officials and staff at Estabrook Elementary School violated state law and civil rights by indoctrinating their children about a lifestyle they, as Christians, teach is immoral.
"Wolf's ruling is every parent's nightmare. It goes to extraordinary lengths to legitimize and reinforce the 'right' (and even the duty) of schools to normalize homosexual behavior to even the youngest of children," said a statement from the pro-family group Mass Resistance.
It also is making available background information about the lengthy dispute.
"In the ruling, Wolf makes the absurd claim that normalizing homosexuality to young children is 'reasonably related to the goals of preparing students to become engaged and productive citizens in our democracy.' According to Wolf, this means teaching 'diversity' which includes 'differences in sexual orientation.'
"In addition, Wolf makes the odious statement that the Parkers' only options are (1) send their kids to a private school, (2) home-school their kids, or (3) elect a majority of people to the School Committee who agree with them. Can you imagine a federal judge in the Civil Rights era telling blacks the same thing that if they can't be served at a lunch counter they should just start their own restaurant, or elect a city council to pass laws that reflect the U.S. Constitution?" the organization said.
Lawyers for the families said they already had planned an appeal of the judge's opinion.
But Wolf's claims followed very closely the reasoning submitted earlier in a brief by Human Rights Campaign, the ACLU, Massachusetts Teachers Association, Gay & Lesbian Advocates & Defenders and other advocates for the "gay" agenda.
Earlier, Mass Resistance President Brian Camenker had wondered why such national groups were "so interested in a parent's right to decide what moral issues are taught to his children by adults in elementary schools, especially regarding
"They must see David Parker's case as quite a threat to their ability to push their message on children," he had said. His organization has posted information about the judge's ruling on the Internet for readers to review
But the judge concluded that even allowing Christians to withdraw their children from classes or portions of classes where the religious beliefs were being violated wasn't a reasonable expectation.
"An exodus from class when issues of homosexuality or same-sex marriage are to be discussed could send the message that gays, lesbians, and the children of same-sex parents are inferior and, therefore, have a damaging effect on those students," he opined.
"Under the Constitution public schools are entitled to teach anything that is reasonably related to the goals of preparing students to become engaged and productive citizens in our democracy," the judge wrote. "Diversity is a hallmark of our nation. It is increasingly evident that our diversity includes differences in sexual orientation."
And, he said, since history "includes instances of official discrimination against gays and lesbians it is reasonable for public educators to teach elementary school students different sexual orientations."
If they disagree, "the Parkers and Wirthlins may send their children to a private school [or] may also educate their children at home," the judge said.
Parker was arrested and jailed in Lexington in April 2005 over his request and the school's refusal to notify him when adults discuss homosexuality or transgenderism with his 6-year-old kindergartner. That despite a state law requiring such notification.
The incident made news around the nation and even Gov. Mitt Romney agreed with Parker.
However, in April 2006 the same school presented the book "King and King," about homosexual romances and marriage, to second-graders and again refused to provide notification.
Parker and other parents followed with the federal civil rights lawsuit, alleging school officials were refusing to follow state law.
Just days later, David Parker's son, Jacob, was beaten up at Estabrook Elementary, officials said. MassResistance said a group of 8-10 kids surrounded him and took him out of sight of "patrolling aides," then pummeled and beat him.
"The state must fight 'discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation' in ways that 'do not perpetuate stereotypes,'" the lawyers for the school district had argued at an earlier motions hearing. They also explained to the judge that, in their opinion, parents have no right to control what ideas the school presents to elementary schoolchildren.
"David Parker's dilemma threatens the parental rights and religious freedom of every Massachusetts parent, and indirectly every parent in America," said John Haskins of the Parents' Rights Coalition.
"As the Lexington schools themselves are arguing, the state's right to force pro-homosexuality indoctrination on other people's children arises directly from former Gov. Mitt Romney's nakedly false and unconstitutional declaration that homosexual marriage is now legal."
Haskins said when the Massachusetts state Supreme Court demanded homosexual marriages in the state, it didn't have the constitutional or legal authority to order the governor to act or to order the Legislature to make any changes, and the creation of same-sex marriages in Massachusetts actually was accomplished by executive order from Romney.
"A federal judge in Massachusetts has ordered the "gay" agenda taught to Christians who attend a public school in Massachusetts, finding that they need the teachings to be "engaged and productive citizens."
Sounds like something a Nazi would say.
Indoctrination is not teaching, it is forced brainwashing.
I hope this helps Christians in Mass. to more clearly see the true nature of government education.
Under threat of sanction
Moral relativism at its worst.
Many "mainstream" churches will probably view this as a good thing. Unfortunately.
Do not hesitate to home educate.
I am waiting for the first Gay Divorce.
Now that will be TV!!
...another reason NOT to vote for him.
Seriously, this is one indicator of why public schools are failing miserably: because they place too much emphasis on brainwashing young students instead of actually teaching them how to read, write, and speak effectively...and about the history of our nation...and basic mathematic and scientific principles (like, for example, the scientific method).
I defer to Ron Stoppable from the Kim Possible movie "A Sitch in Time": when he and Kim were being taken to the indoctrination center in "Shegoton" by the drones, the drone told them, "Prepare to be drained of all individuality and spirit." Ron replied, "Yup. High school."
You must be confusing religion with run of the mill cults. "Mainstream churches" who would see this a "good thing" are simply cults disguising themselves in Christianity.
EXACTLY. While our 6 year olds are learning about sharing, diversity, and otherwise feeling good about who they are, our 12 year olds are lucky if they can multiply two-two digit numbers and read and comprehend the instructions on a box of macaroni and cheese.
Forget about writing. It's keyboarding now. I'm not sure they even teach cursive anymore.
That's funny, I must have missed that part where the Constitution says anything about "public schools", "entitled to teach anything", "to become engaged"
They must be in the ACLU Cliff notes the judge carries around
The judge is unfit to sit on a bench.
...another reason NOT to vote for him.
Romney agreed with the parent that brought the lawsuit...and that's a reason NOT to vote for him? I don't get it.
READ this judge's ruling!
The Peoples Republic of Massachusetts is following the Communist Manifesto pretty much. The State is degenerate and corrupt IMO. I lived there for a long four years. I was stunned by the extent of the underground economy, the oppressive tax system, the corruption, and the rampant hyprocrisy! It is definitely a Democratic state. Just double the cost of automobile insurance premiums, home owner's insurance, State income taxes, etc. if you plan to move there.
This dude is completely off his rocker...
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.