Posted on 12/05/2006 10:10:32 AM PST by jveritas
Based on what on what Defense Secretary nominee Mr. Gates has said so far in the Senate confirmation hearings, it is easy to conclude that he is a “Defeatist”. No matter how tough the situation is in Iraq he must not say in public that we are not winning the war in Iraq. That is totally demoralizing to our troops and will further embolden our enemies there like Al Qaeda, Iran, and Syria. Moreover the man has shown extreme ambiguity and uncertainty in his answers to many questions.
I doubt very much that he told the President that we are not winning in Iraq or else the President would not have nominated him. It may be too late to withdraw his nomination now, but our country and most importantly our brave troops deserve a better person to be the Secretary of Defense.
This guy was on the Baker-Hamilton Commission. When the report comes out, and calls for a cut-and-run, how will he be able to oppose it, given that he helped write it??? Bush has painted us into a corner.
Defeatist? Why? Because he told the truth? Are you suggesting he lie?
How is that defeatist?
Do you think Churchill claimed Britain was "winning" the war when Germany was bombing London? Of course not. But he sure as heck didn't give up either.
Yes, I prefer to have a SecDef who is delusional, closed-minded, tells the American public that things are going well in Iraq...
Oh, wait that guy just got canned.
In which case, we may have 2 1/2 mores years of Rumsfeld :-). Maybe gates is a "Harriet Miers" nominee.
Cut and Run is now being supported by the new Defense Secretary, and when Levin endorses him, you KNOW we've lost for sure, as he will give the Democrats all the ammo they need to tout their cut and run agenda.
Cut and Run is now being supported by the new Defense Secretary, and when Levin endorses him, you KNOW we've lost for sure, as he will give the Democrats all the ammo they need to tout their cut and run agenda.
God help us all.
The wrong people have been thrown under the bus.
Bush himself should have taken the hit. Then at least we would have Cheney in the White House, Rummy still at DOD, Porter Goss at CIA, Ashcroft at DOJ, and John Bolton at UN. And someone a hell of a lot more conservative at State.
Gates is saying what he needs to in order to get confirmed.
Less knee jerking, please.
Next time I'd like to see you use "cut and run" THREE times in one sentence!
We need to keep Iraq out of the terrorist sphere and we need to move forward to deal with (I mean confront) Syria and Iran. If they will still do that I'm ok with it.
He'll be confirmed, most likely by the end of the week, most likely unanimously, by voice vote. The new US policy on Iraq is cut and run.
What is it with the Class of 98?
Sounds like he's telling the Senators what they need to hear in order to vote for his confirmation. Cynical, but the only method that works.
Extreem honesty doesn't work. Ask Robert Bork.
President Bush is a Lincoln surrounded by McClellans. Where have you gone, William Tecumseh Sherman?
Elections have consequences and thanks to "them" for not voting the 110th congress will be pulling the troops or cut funding, either way we are leaving Iraq
Defeat is in the air. Dontcha know many think they won by losing in November. Soon we can get Iraq behind us and go to war with Mexico. All we need is a leader... (sound of crickets chirping).
By maintaining the current course, defeat is assured. Patton and McArthur and Pershing and Sherman and Washington would be horrified at the military position we find ourselves in.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.