Prenatal Screening not so Accurate as Once Thought – “Normal” Children Killed as “Defective”?

LifeSiteNews ^ | 11/24/06 | Hilary White

[wagglebee]

The Globe and Mail quotes Steve Scherer, a senior scientist at the Hospital for Sick Children in Toronto and study co-author, “The genome is like an accordion that can stretch or shrink . . . so you have no idea what's normal.”

Yet genetic screening by eugenicists grows more common.

[wagglebee]

Pro-Life Ping

[wagglebee]

Moral Absolutes Ping!

Freepmail wagglebee or little jeremiah to subscribe or unsubscribe from the moral absolutes ping list.

FreeRepublic moral absolutes keyword search
[ Add keyword moral absolutes to flag FR articles to this ping list ]

The Culture of Death is doing tests that Hitler only dreamed of.

[pinkpanther111]

Mt. Sinai recommends genetic counselling for “couples who already have a child with mental retardation, an inherited disorder or a birth defect… (and) women over the age of 35 who are pregnant or planning to be.” This age group has a significantly higher, although still very low percentage chance of conceiving a child with Down syndrome.

At age 35 the chance of conceiving a Downs child is estimated to be 1 in 400 or one-quarter of one percent of conceptions. At age 40 it becomes 1 percent and for conceptions over age 45 the overall average increases to 4 percent. However, 75 percent of all babies with Down syndrome are born to women under 35.

Mt Sinai says, “When a birth defect is diagnosed, genetic counsellors provide emotional support during what can be a very difficult time. If there are decisions to be made about the pregnancy…. the parents can make more informed choices with the facts in hand.”

_______________________________________________

I refused this test when I was pregnant. Decisions about the pregnancy... In otherwords get an abortion.

[Myrddin]

Mt Sinai says, “When a birth defect is diagnosed, genetic counsellors provide emotional support during what can be a very difficult time. If there are decisions to be made about the pregnancy…. the parents can make more informed choices with the facts in hand.”

Informed choices? My first son arrived with heart problems and ADD. When my wife was pregnant with #2 son, the doctor professing to be a "genetic counselor" and expert in his field recommended aborting the pregnancy. #2 son arrived in perfect health. He graduated high school with a 4.33 GPA, put himself though college to earn a BS in Business Administration, earned a CA real estate broker's license, employs 26 people and still serves his country as a USMC reserve. The "genetic expert" was an obvious quack. I say that with a bit of authority as a molecular biologist/genetics engineer. I shudder to think how many perfectly normal children have been sucked into a sink based on his ignorant advice.

[metmom]

ping

[speekinout]

A friend's grandson was diagnosed as Down's syndrome in utero. The parents spent months discussing how they would deal with their Down's son. Wasted time. He's 5 now, and a real delight. He's perfect.
Thank God that he had parents who were willing to take whatever they were given.

[I still care]

I know of at least 2 children that the doctors said would be abnormal, and applied a lot of pressure to abort. Both were perfect.

I also know of a child who the doctors said would be terribly abnormal, and really pushed the Mom to abort. She defied them, and delivered a child that while not physically perfect, is a delight to all that know her. She is active in our church and we love her dearly.

It's an evil culture that does not recognize the special sacred worth of each person.

[sine_nomine]

Ditto for us. My wife said, "So we should test the unborn child and then kill it? Why?" The doctor backed down 100%.

[Scotswife]

It was recommended to my sister that she have an abortion based on results from the screening.
She went into labor 1 month earlier than expected and gave birth to a full term baby.
As it turned out - they got her due date wrong - which skewed the testing results.

Thank goodness she didn't listen to them.

[metmom]

I was offered alpha fetal protein testing to check for birth defects. I asked if that was the test that gave false positives so that only 1:80 was anything MIGHT be a legitimate concern but still didn't necessarily mean that anything was wrong (like twins would give a false positive). The nurse practitioner (the ob's wife) said, "Yes", so I said, "No, because even if there was something wrong, abortion was not an option." She stopped what she was writing, looked me in the eye, and said, "I wish more people felt that way." (They had at least six kids themselves). There's good ones out there.

[little jeremiah]

It's an evil culture that does not recognize the special sacred worth of each person.

No matter what physical or mental capabilities. Sometimes people opposed to abortion say things like "suppose Einstein was aborted" or some other great person. Every soul is precious and worthy; we're all handicapped in one way or another.

[beezdotcom]

I know of at least 2 children that the doctors said would be abnormal, and applied a lot of pressure to abort. Both were perfect.

I know similar cases - and frighteningly, I think *many* people know cases like this.

I also know people so advised who *did* have abnormal children - and yet, they still loved those children, for the few minutes they shared with them before they died. Sometimes, your job as a parent lasts only a few minutes - but it's still your job to perform.

[Marie]

When I was a teenager I got into a *lot* of trouble. I smoked, drank, stayed out all night, ran away, etc.

But I always managed to keep myself out of the *really* bad stuff.

I tried to keep my body relatively "clean" because of simple biology. I'd learned that I was carrying all the eggs that I would ever have. Every potential child was half-way formed, just waiting for a father. I felt that I was already sharing my body with my future children and that I had no right to endanger them.

I've taught my own daughter this lesson. "You're already a mother. The babies are there. It's your responsibility to protect them now by protecting yourself, choose their father wisely, then keep them from killing themselves until they're grown." (I love that she "gets" me!) ;-)

[diamond6]

Marie, that is a really great way of putting that; thanks for sharing.

:)

[Marie]

Yeah... and as soon as hubby and I decided not to have any more children I ran out and got a tattoo!

(Dang, I crack myself up!)

[Yaelle]

Every young couple starting to have a family should be told this. The genetic tests might only let you know your child is a carrier of something. Ultrasounds saying your child has a defect that is "incompatible with life" are sometimes WRONG. Every baby deserves to begin life, if G-d sends him here.

I have seen too many cases where a doctor wants to abort for silly reasons. Here are two from my SMALL circle of friends. One normal pregnancy was recommended aborted because the mother had a bone tumor that turned out to be benign. While true that she would have had to spend her pregnancy in some chronic pain and on crutches, her baby would have been born healthy. She aborted the baby on doctor's recommendation, in a fit of fear about her own mortality and the tumor.

The other mother needs your prayers today. She is a religious Christian mommy in the hospital tonight because in her uterus with her little baby girl (25 weeks along) is a subchorionic bleed (like a clot of blood keeping her bleeding), and very little amniotic fluid. We are all praying she makes it until the baby's lungs are developed enough to survive outside the womb. She now has a Christian doctor. The previous one told her she should abort.

This goes on ALL the time. People are told "Your baby will never live, never be normal, etc." I guess the doctors have to perform "CYA," but so many of those babies go on to become happy little children.

[Yaelle]

Exactly. I have read the stories of the parents who were forever grateful that their little ones were able to be born and pass away, loved, in their parents' arms. How meaningful their short lives were to the whole family and how important it was to know that they Were, and that they could then be mourned, missed, and waited for until we all meet again in a better place.

[TheresaKett]

I was 36 when I got pregnant and the doctor insisted that I get this test, even though I told her that I was having the baby even if it had any abnormal results. I got mad at the doctor and she finally confided that the state will not pay for the care of a child that the parent refuses to abort if they test positive. I have no idea if that is true or not, but I still insisted that I would never kill my child, no matter what. He is perfectly normal today.

I have also know several friends who tested positive for Down babies, that turned out just fine.

[TheresaKett]

The other mother needs your prayers today. She is a religious Christian mommy in the hospital tonight because in her uterus with her little baby girl (25 weeks along) is a subchorionic bleed (like a clot of blood keeping her bleeding), and very little amniotic fluid. We are all praying she makes it until the baby's lungs are developed enough to survive outside the womb. She now has a Christian doctor. The previous one told her she should abort.

prayers for your friend and her baby