[Sir Francis Dashwood]

If the New York Republicans and Giuliani himself are so happy to sit on their hands and let Hillary Clinton be their senator, why the hell should the rest of the Republicans suffer their incompetence on the national stage???

[GeorgefromGeorgia]

Your logic is that Rudy is not a good Presidential candidate because he probably could have beaten Hillary for the Senate. This reminds me of some RATs that blame Bush for everything. Rudy had a health reason for not running, and even if he didn't, that would be no reason to criticize him now.