[Dog]

found the "military commissions" illegal under both military justice law and the Geneva convention.

Yes ...but they are not covered by the Geneva convention.

[IMRight]

Yes ...but they are not covered by the Geneva convention.

Of course they are.

[Mo1]

Yes ...but they are not covered by the Geneva convention.

So what happens now?

[tarheelswamprat]

found the "military commissions" illegal under both military justice law and the Geneva convention.

Yes ...but they are not covered by the Geneva convention.

Correct. This wasn't really a legal ruling by the Supreme Court, it was a political ruling. It was just another skirmish in the ongoing power struggle between the different branches of government.

We have finally reached the point where our government is at war with terrorists, at war with its own citizens, and at war with itself.

[Dead Dog]

Uh, the USSC overstepped their authority to rule on the GC or UCMJ.