[AndrewC]

I said reputation as a researcher, not ability to sell books.

Nice feint, but you attacked her because of what she wrote. Her title is not researcher.

[OmahaFields]

I think he attacked her for not having a basis for what she wrote.

[Coyoteman]

I said reputation as a researcher, not ability to sell books.

Nice feint, but you attacked her because of what she wrote. Her title is not researcher.

I commented on the quality of the research; in the sections on evolution, it was not good.

When you do a book, it is your responsibility to do the research. That means, scholarship. If you cite a reference, cite it correctly, not what somebody else says about it. Read the original article, know what it says, and cite it correctly.

Didn't a lot of the citations go back to the New York Times?