Skip to comments.
'Tenth Planet' found to be a whopper
news@nature.com ^
| 1 February 2006
| Mark Peplow
Posted on 02/02/2006 9:25:14 PM PST by neverdem
![](/images/spacer.gif) |
![](/news/images/spacer_black.gif) |
![](/news/images/spacer.gif) Published online: 1 February 2006; | doi:10.1038/news060130-7 'Tenth Planet' found to be a whopperLarge size of 2003 UB313 fuels debate over what is and isn't a planet.Mark Peplow
The recently discovered 'tenth planet' of our Solar System is substantially larger than Pluto, astronomers have found.
For many, the discovery that object 2003 UB313 is about 3,000 kilometres across will remove any doubt that it deserves to be called a planet.
"Since UB313 is decidedly larger than Pluto, it is now increasingly hard to justify calling Pluto a planet if UB313 is not also given this status," says Frank Bertoldi, an astronomer at the Max Planck Institute for Radioastronomy in Bonn, Germany, and part of the team that reveals UB313's size in this week's Nature1.
When astronomer Mike Brown of the California Institute of Technology in Pasadena unveiled 2003 UB313 to the world in July 2005, his team was already confident that the new object was at least as large as Pluto, and deserved the status of 'planet'.
But UB313's elongated orbit takes it almost twice as far away from the Sun as Pluto ever gets, making it very difficult to measure its diameter precisely. One clue to its larger size came from the fact that it is slightly brighter than Pluto; a larger mirror would reflect more of the Sun's light. But an alternative explanation could have been that UB313 is simply made of a more reflective material than Pluto.
Ice maiden
Using the Institute for Millimetre Radio Astronomy (IRAM) 30-metre telescope in Spain, Bertoldi's team has now studied the radiowaves coming from UB313, which reveal how much of the Sun's rays are absorbed and re-radiated as heat. Because very little reflected sunlight is emitted at these wavelengths, the object's brightness in radiowaves depends only on its size and surface temperature.
Based on its enormous distance from the Sun, UB313 is calculated to be tremendously cold: a staggering -248 °C. Bertoldi and his colleagues combined this value with their measurements of UB313's radiation to determine its reflectivity and size.
Although this first estimate of 3,000 kilometres may be out by as much as 400 kilometres, this still puts UB313 well ahead of 2,300-kilometre-wide Pluto in the size stakes, making it the largest body found in the Solar System since the discovery of Neptune in 1846.
The research also shows that UB313 has a reflectivity, or albedo, of about 60%. This is roughly the same as Pluto's, suggesting that the two objects' surfaces are made of very similar materials, such as frozen methane and nitrogen snow. Only a very frosty world could produce an albedo of 60%, says Brown.
Imagine how you'd feel if your baby didn't have a name for seven months. ![](/news/images/columns_qt_right.gif) |
![](/images/spacer.gif)
|
|
![](/images/spacer.gif) |
![](/images/spacer.gif) |
Brown has also been trying to measure the size of UB313 by using the Hubble Space Telescope. Although he released preliminary findings on 25 January at a public meeting at Foothill College in Los Altos Hill, California, suggesting that UB313 was just a few percent larger than Pluto, he now says that measurement is wrong. "It was an extremely preliminary estimate," he explains.
A planet with no name
2003 UB313 is not the catchiest name, but unfortunately this temporary designation will have to stick until the International Astronomical Union (IAU) decides whether it is indeed a planet that warrants a name from classical mythology.
Since 1992, more than 1,000 similar, albeit smaller, objects have been found in the region around Pluto known as the Kuiper Belt, and astronomers estimate that there may be more than half a million still waiting to be discovered. As more of these icy remnants from the Solar System's birth turn up, Pluto blends into the crowd and its claim to be a unique planet grows slimmer and slimmer.
Some astronomers argue that Pluto should be stripped of its title, to become a Kuiper Belt Object like its orbital fellows. Others suggest that anything larger than Pluto found in the outskirts of the Solar System should also be called a 'planet', which would include UB313. "I'd prefer to keep Pluto as a planet, for historical reasons," says Bertoldi.
The IAU set up a committee of 19 top astronomers to come up with a workable definition for a planet that would rule UB313 in or out, but in November 2005 the group finally admitted defeat after failing to reach a clear consensus. The IAU has promised action later this year, but Brown is already impatient. "Imagine how you'd feel if your baby didn't have a name for seven months," he says.
Post a comment to this story by visiting our newsblog.
References
Bertoldi F., Altenhoff W., Weiss A., Menten K. M.& Thum C. . Nature, 439 . 563 - 564 (2006). | Article | |
|
![](/news/images/spacer_black.gif) |
![](/news/images/spacer.gif) Story from news@nature.com: http://news.nature.com//news/2006/060130/060130-7.html |
|
![](/images/spacer.gif) |
|
TOPICS: Culture/Society; Extended News; Germany; News/Current Events; US: California
KEYWORDS: 10thplanet; 2003ub313; gabrielle; nibiru; planet; planetx; pluto; tenthplanet; xena; xenalyte; xplanets
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-20, 21-40, 41-60, 61-80 ... 121-126 next last
To: Darksheare; neverdem
I think we're getting reports of larger-than-Jupiter worlds and closer-than-Mercury giants because of the limits of the observing technology, which has been improving all the time since the late 1990s, when the first confirmed extrasolar planet was discovered.
The issues raised by these seemingly anomalous systems are real ones, however. :')
http://seds.lpl.arizona.edu/nineplanets/nineplanets/other.html
"Observations of the very nearby Barnard's Star were once thought to be evidence of gravitational effects of planets but they now seem to have been in error."
21
posted on
02/02/2006 9:58:02 PM PST
by
SunkenCiv
(In the long run, there is only the short run.)
To: neverdem
They found another 10th planet yesterday?
22
posted on
02/02/2006 9:58:16 PM PST
by
presidio9
("Bird Flu" is the new Y2K virus -only without the handy deadline.)
To: Ichneumon
Yes.
And as detection becomes easier and better refined, we may find that our style solar system is more common.
But with Jupiter, Staurn, Uranus, and Nptune in our solar system, how come ours didn't end up mosty toasty like others?
That's probably a question broiling in the backs of some minds at the moment.
(Perhaps our sun was a bit of a stellar oddball and put enough outward pressure to keep things from infalling early on?)
23
posted on
02/02/2006 9:58:17 PM PST
by
Darksheare
(Aim low! They got knees!)
To: SunkenCiv
24
posted on
02/02/2006 9:59:00 PM PST
by
Darksheare
(Aim low! They got knees!)
To: Darksheare
"Seems our solar system is a bit of an oddball."
The more we explore our own backyard, the more weird stuff we discover. Our system is a cornucopia of oddities and unanswered questions.
25
posted on
02/02/2006 10:03:47 PM PST
by
Army Air Corps
(Four fried chickens and a coke)
To: Army Air Corps
Yeah, What would make it'frosting on the cake' would be to find we are living in a binary star system with a brown dwarf secondary star orbiting our primary star..
That would be something to hear about.
26
posted on
02/02/2006 10:08:15 PM PST
by
Darksheare
(Aim low! They got knees!)
To: demlosers
"What shall we call it? Minerva, Vesta, Diana, Bacchus, Juno, or Vulcan?"
![](http://www.mythfolklore.net/mywiki/images/spock.jpg)
"I do have a preference."
27
posted on
02/02/2006 10:09:36 PM PST
by
Army Air Corps
(Four fried chickens and a coke)
To: neverdem
![](http://www.e-jul.com/images/whopper.jpg)
Here's a picture from the Hubble space telescope.
To: Darksheare
"What would make it'frosting on the cake' would be to find we are living in a binary star system with a brown dwarf secondary star orbiting our primary star."
I'll settle for a stable wormhole. :-)
29
posted on
02/02/2006 10:10:50 PM PST
by
Army Air Corps
(Four fried chickens and a coke)
To: Darksheare
My pleasure. Thanks for the link to the Moving Orbits topic. :')
30
posted on
02/02/2006 10:10:54 PM PST
by
SunkenCiv
(In the long run, there is only the short run.)
To: neverdem
I say we call it Ceres.
Of course, Ceres was the goddess of motherly love and agriculture (or something), which kinda clashes with a cold, barren, icy rock floating around millions of miles away from the sun...
But in mythology, Ceres is related to Jupiter, Saturn, Neptune and Pluto, so she'd fit in nicely with our current solar system.
31
posted on
02/02/2006 10:13:11 PM PST
by
Termite_Commander
(Warning: Cynical Right-winger Ahead)
To: Paleo Conservative
It must be getting late, as I stared at that for about seven seconds, and then began laughing.
My brain is slowing down.
32
posted on
02/02/2006 10:14:30 PM PST
by
Termite_Commander
(Warning: Cynical Right-winger Ahead)
To: Darksheare; neverdem; NormsRevenge; RadioAstronomer
It's just a special place;
To: Paleo Conservative
![](http://www.e-jul.com/images/whopper.jpg)
Here's a picture from the Hubble space telescope.
![](http://adweek.blogs.com/photos/uncategorized/bk_birds.jpg)
One of the planet's inhabitants.
34
posted on
02/02/2006 10:17:56 PM PST
by
JRios1968
("Cogito, ergo FReep": I think, therefore I FReep.)
To: neverdem
![](http://www.nature.com/news/2006/060130/images/060130-7_large.jpg)
2003 UB313 is currently the fifteenth-largest known Solar System object, with a diameter larger than those of Pluto and the neptunian moon Triton, but smaller than those of Earth's Moon and Titan, the largest of Saturn's satellites. Other objects, besides the eight undisputed major planets, that are larger than 2003 UB313 are Jupiter's satellites Callisto, Io, Europa (not pictured) and Ganymede (the largest moon in the Solar System). Behind Pluto, the next-largest known trans-neptunian objects are 2005 FY9, with a diameter of about 1,800 km, and Sedna (1,700 km). A handful more are larger than Ceres, the largest asteroid in the main asteroid belt between Mars and Jupiter. .
To: Ernest_at_the_Beach
Oh, drat. Ceres already exists?
Now I need to pick out another name.
How tedious!
36
posted on
02/02/2006 10:20:35 PM PST
by
Termite_Commander
(Warning: Cynical Right-winger Ahead)
To: SunkenCiv
37
posted on
02/02/2006 10:25:23 PM PST
by
neverdem
(May you be in heaven a half hour before the devil knows that you're dead.)
To: Ernest_at_the_Beach
Do they make heavenly body bowling balls? A Ganymede bowling ball would be sweet.
38
posted on
02/02/2006 10:28:42 PM PST
by
Rastus
39
posted on
02/02/2006 10:38:54 PM PST
by
SunkenCiv
(In the long run, there is only the short run.)
To: SunkenCiv
It's so lonely out there!
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-20, 21-40, 41-60, 61-80 ... 121-126 next last
Disclaimer:
Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual
posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its
management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the
exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson