[RGSpincich]

The something fishy is that the property is not a resort but a bunch of condos. The owners of some lease their units out through leasing agents, not Baytree. The other units are occupied by residents as in a residential neighborhood. The shock of 117 new party animals into the neighborhood may have prompted more than a few complaints from the existing residents. Baytree settled after winning the initial court decision ( I am assuming this because the family filed an appeal here ) probably to avoid further mischaracterizations in the press.

[MEGoody]

The something fishy is that the property is not a resort but a bunch of condos.

Then it's too bad they had to settle. They have the right to lock down the pool to keep more than 100 'guests' from overwhelming the facility.

[ExitPurgamentum]

The shock of 117 new party animals into the neighborhood may have prompted more than a few complaints from the existing residents.

The way to deal with that is to pass a bylaw limiting the size of parties that may rent the facilities. If there were no such bylaws, you let the party go through and then amend your bylaws.