Posted on 06/25/2005 11:40:09 AM PDT by Lorianne
Isn't an oud a lute, i.e. another form of guitar?
Hey bud, How you doing.
Theory is the same, tone is different.
Middle eastern music is a completely different animal.
They have different scales, different timing than you think of Coming from an Exposure to Western music.
A lot of Western instruments have been incorporated in recent times.
Via e-mail, I asked Claude Andrew Clegg III, author of another Elijah Muhammad biography, An Original Man, to give me his take on the controversy. Clegg, a history professor at the University of Indiana at Bloomington, responded: The version of the story that characterizes Fard as being of Pakistani descent and having a criminal background seems to have some validity, though neither allegation has been conclusively proven. What seems most remarkable is that Fard seems to have utterly disappeared from the governments (especially the FBIs) radar after leaving Detroit in 1933. There were rumors about his whereabouts until the 1990s, when some believed he was still alive and living somewhere in California. Whatever the case, Fard was a master at remaking himself and was apparently a very charismatic man. Also, in many ways, the Nation of Islams depiction of him as God could only work and be credible to potential members if his origins remained obscure and his disappearance permanent.
In other words, a very elaborate criminal enterprise.
What about the Oud and Nej, found under varying names in most Persian, North African, and Lebanese music? There goes some of the best Middle Eastern classical and modern music! (I guess Span-Arabic pop is no great loss ...)
I concur, having made the same observations.
peace to you all
i was just searching the web looking for more information on native deen.. and this little article seemed to pop up and so as any1 else wuld.. i started reading it.. and i found it very intresting but wat i found even more intresting was the replies and opinions on native deen.. and hw nearly every single person who replied seem to have known eveything about islam although they were nt muslims. they also seem to think that all muslims are arab... which is very suprising cos as far as im concerned dat is nt true. i also was astonished to read hw "muslims" are the slave masters... nw obviously ppl have gotten confused with "muslims" and arabs" thease are two different types of ppl.... its funny hw ppl who are nt muslims seem to answer there questions about islam themself.... nw as far as i knw if u have question on islam the best person to ask wuld be a muslim since they follow that deen... so if u guys have any question to ask ill feel free to answer dem.... anyhooo im off
as a matter of fact it is true that the teachings of the prophet Muhammad (s.a.w) forbid the playing of most musical instruments, as it clearly says in the hadith (teachings and sayings of Muhammad). You can't judge what islam says by looking at other people who don't follow the religion correctly. It would be best you take a closer look into the hadeeth and the Quran, which gives you a complete explanation and guideline of how one should live their life as a true,devout muslim.
You dug up a thread that has been dead for 7 months to comment on.
A trivial and insignificant thread.
You got a problem?
Sounds like 'must see'.
First, rap ain't music. Second rap is hard enough to listen to, but when the only accompaniement is drums...!
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.