This is just typical moronic "feel good" thinking. Sort of like last year's clamor to shut down Abu Gharib.
Unless we're going to RELEASE these terrorists, they will have to be housed SOMEWHERE. Gitmo is as good a place as any.
I am against holding people indefinately but if they are charging them and giving them trials then I see no problem with that.
Well you may be right, but then again I bet if we looked really hard we could find a deserted Island with little or no water and damned little to eat and just maroon them there without having to furnish guards. Please keep the location secret .