[conshack]

One also has to take into account that this was a 2nd Lt, not a seasoned combat officer. He likely had little military experience and even more minimal combat experience.
I have to stress again that we have lost a number of soldiers in Iraq due to terrorists being treated as non-combatants(who in actuality are combatants). Also have to agree that there may have been some bad judgements made here, but none that rise to the guy being charged with murder.

[Poohbah]

One also has to take into account that this was a 2nd Lt, not a seasoned combat officer. He likely had little military experience and even more minimal combat experience.

Again, you are wrong; Lt. Pantano is prior enlisted, and he was a sniper in Desert Storm. So he doesn't have the "I'm just a dumb second looie" defense available.

[colorado tanker]

but none that rise to the guy being charged with murder

From what I've read, I agree. If this thing goes to trial, which I doubt, it looks like it will come down to who the jury believes, Lt. Pantano or the NCO who claims Lt. Pantano was not acting in self defense.