According to Peggy a few references to God is "too much". Something wrong with that thinking.
Susan Estrich said a that a fellow member of her party was "off in the head" because he didn't tow the party line. You are saying that a fellow member of your party is "off in the head" because she didn't tow the party line.
Maybe Noonan's analysis is off, but that doesn't mean that something is wrong with her. Most here believe that Bush's analysis of the immigration issue is faulty - again, that doesn't mean that something is wrong with the man.